Er Gen Novels Novels & Stories

Looking for the top er gen author this year really depends on what you're valuing most. If we're talking sheer dominance within the genre's online sphere and the ability to consistently hook readers with massive, intricate worlds, I don't see how it's not I Eat Tomatoes. His latest series feels like it's everywhere in my feeds, and the community hype is unreal. The scale is just bonkers, even for xianxia.

That said, 'top' can mean different things. Some folks I chat with argue that the prose quality and character depth in works from authors like Mao Ni or Tang Jia San Shao have a staying power that pure scale sometimes lacks. But in terms of 2024 momentum and defining the current conversation? Tomato's holding the crown, hands down. My reading list is basically just his updates lately.

I think the process is deeply tied to their xianxia/xuanhuan traditions. A lot of it seems to start with a core 'gimmick'—a unique cultivation system or a twist on reincarnation—and then they just build outwards, layer by layer, often as they're serializing. You'll notice the best ones plant seeds for distant realms or higher planes of existence early on, even if they're just names dropped casually. The skill is in making the world feel infinitely expandable without collapsing under its own weight.

My personal theory is that reading a ton of classic wuxia and mythology gives them a huge vocabulary of places, creatures, and power hierarchies to remix. They're not building from zero; they're playing with a shared cultural toolkit. The real development happens when they learn to balance the scale. Throwing out 'ten thousand ancient continents' feels empty. Showing a single, crumbling sect at the edge of the wasteland, with its own petty politics and forgotten lore, makes it feel vast.

Often, the map unfolds alongside the protagonist's growth. The village, the city, the sect, the kingdom, the continent, the higher realm—it's a narrative scaffold. The authors who get good at it learn to give each 'layer' its own distinct flavor and internal logic before the MC blows past it forever.

Honestly, the most common name that pops up in this convo is Er Gen himself, but if we're talking authors who write in a similar 'grand cultivation epic' lane that gets super popular, I'd point to I Eat Tomatoes. His 'Stellar Transformations' and 'Coiling Dragon' are basically the gateway drugs for a ton of western readers into xianxia. They don't have the same bitter, cyclical tragedy as Er Gen's stuff, but they nail that sense of vast, universe-spanning progression and power scaling that feels very Er Gen-esque in scope.

That said, the obsession with fate and reincarnation in 'I Shall Seal the Heavens' is pretty unique to Er Gen. Authors like Tang Jia San Shao, with 'Douluo Dalu', focus more on inventive combat systems and a cleaner, shounen-like hero's journey. For that specific blend of philosophical melancholy and world-breaking power, Er Gen still feels like his own niche. I see his influence more in how later authors structure their long-term cultivation stages than in outright copying his tone.