Okay, here’s my enthusiastic hot take: if you want translations that actually let the Chinese novels breathe in English, start with the ones that readers and scholars keep pointing to again and again.
For modern sci‑fi and genre stuff, 'The Three-Body Problem' translated by Ken Liu is a standout — he keeps the scientific chill and the human smallness intact while making the prose sing in English. For contemporary literary voices, Howard Goldblatt’s translations (think 'Red Sorghum' and many of Mo Yan’s books) feel very natural; he smooths difficult idioms without losing the original’s bite. When you want faithful, annotated classics, Anthony C. Yu’s multivolume 'Journey to the West' is academic gold: dense, full of cultural notes, and astonishingly readable for such a massive work.
If you crave the canonical Chinese novels, the usual holy trinity has reliable English renderings: David Hawkes (with John Minford completing later volumes) for 'Dream of the Red Chamber' is lyrical and painstaking; Moss Roberts’ 'Romance of the Three Kingdoms' balances scholarship with readability; Arthur Waley’s 'Monkey' (his version of 'Journey to the West') is lighter and brilliant for first-timers. For older yet influential translations, Pearl S. Buck’s 'All Men Are Brothers' (the 'Water Margin') is dated but historically important — I treat it like a doorway, then move on to more modern editions.
Beyond who translated what, I always hunt for editions with good footnotes and an introduction explaining cultural references. That context changes everything. Personally, I bounce between a cosy, narrative translation for pleasure and a fuller, annotated one when I want to dig deeper — both are valid ways to enjoy these books.