The knight in 'The Fallen Duke and the Knight Who Hated Him' is Sir Gareth, a character who’s as complex as he is compelling. At first glance, he seems like your typical stoic, duty-bound warrior, but the story peels back layers to reveal a man grappling with loyalty, betrayal, and a simmering resentment toward the titular fallen duke. What makes Gareth fascinating is how his hatred isn’t one-dimensional—it’s tangled up in past camaraderie and a sense of disillusionment. The novel does a brilliant job of showing how his rigid moral code clashes with the messy reality of politics and personal relationships.
I love how the author uses flashbacks to contrast Gareth’s earlier idealism with his current cynicism. There’s a particular scene where he refuses to draw his sword against the duke, not out of mercy, but because he considers it 'beneath him'—a moment that perfectly captures his pride and internal conflict. If you enjoy knights who aren’t just shiny paragons but flawed humans, Gareth’s arc is worth following. The way his dynamic with the duke evolves from hostility to something more ambiguous had me glued to the page.