Chapter 6- Matthew

Matthew Cross is still smiling.

That is the most dangerous thing about him — the smile. It is the smile of a man who arrived at this hotel tonight knowing exactly what he would find and is deeply, privately pleased to have been right. He is handsome in a calculated way. Polished. The kind of man who wears confidence like a second suit and knows precisely how it fits.

I shake his hand because refusing would tell him too much.

“Matthew Cross,” I say. Measured. Professional. The voice I use when opposing counsel is trying to rattle me in a deposition. “I’m afraid I don’t recall Michael mentioning you.”

“He wouldn’t.” Something flickers behind his eyes. “Michael and I had a falling out some years ago. Water under the bridge now — mostly.” He tilts his head toward the elevator. “Can I buy you a drink? The bar downstairs is excellent.”

“It’s late,” I say. “I was just leaving.”

“Five minutes.” His smile doesn’t move. “I think you’ll want to hear what I have to say. Considering.”

Considering.

One word. Carrying an entire freight train of implication.

I look at him for three seconds. A lawyer’s three seconds — reading, calculating, deciding. He is not threatening me. Not yet. He is extending an invitation wrapped in a warning, and the correct response is to understand what I am dealing with before deciding how to handle it.

“Five minutes,” I say.

-----

The hotel bar is all low lighting and dark wood, and the quiet luxury of a place where people come to have conversations they cannot have anywhere else. Matthew orders scotch. I order sparkling water and feel his eyes note the choice — the deliberate clarity of it, the refusal to soften my edges for this conversation.

He leans back. Completely at ease. A man in his natural habitat.

“How long have you known Michael?” I ask first. Always ask first. Control the frame.

“Since Harvard.” He turns the scotch glass slowly. “We were close for about four years. Business interests diverged. Then personal interests.” A brief pause loaded with something I cannot yet identify. “I’ve been back in Michael’s orbit for about six months. Consulting work.”

“What kind of consulting?”

“The kind that requires discretion.” He looks at me directly. “Which is something I understand you currently have a significant interest in.”

The bar hums around us. A couple laughs at a nearby table. I wrap both hands around my water glass, hold his gaze, and give him absolutely nothing.

“I don’t know what you think you saw tonight,” I say pleasantly.

“I know exactly what I saw tonight.” Still pleasant. Still smiling. “Room 1403. Samuel Thomas. Eleven o’clock on a Wednesday.” He tilts his head. “I also know about Saturday. And the Wednesday before that.” He pauses. “It’s been going on for three weeks, Khloe. You have been careful. Not careful enough.”

The water glass is cold in my hands. I keep them still.

“What do you want?” I ask. Direct. No more games.

Something shifts in his expression — the pleasantness dropping by one layer, something more real underneath. “Nothing from you,” he says. “Not yet. I want you to understand that I am aware of the situation. And that awareness is currently” — he takes a slow sip of scotch — “contained.”

“Currently,” I repeat.

“Currently.”

I look at him. “Who are you working for?”

His smile returns. Full and sharp. “I told you. Consulting work.”

“Matthew.” I lean forward. “I am a corporate attorney. I have spent eight years sitting across tables from men who believe information is power and leverage is currency. I know exactly what this conversation is. So let’s skip the theatre.” I hold his gaze. “Who sent you?”

He looks at me for a long moment. Then he does something I did not expect — he laughs. Genuine, slightly surprised. “Michael said you were sharp,” he says. “He undersold it.”

“Who. Sent. You.”

He sets his scotch down. The smile fades to something more honest and considerably more complicated. “Nobody sent me tonight,” he says. “Tonight was a coincidence. I’m staying at this hotel. I saw you come out of his room.” He pauses. “The rest — what I know, what I’ve been watching — that is something else. And right now I am deciding what to do with it.”

“You’re deciding,” I say flatly.

“I’m deciding.” He holds my gaze. “I’m not your enemy, Khloe. I want you to know that before we go any further.”

“People who are not my enemy do not corner me in hotel bars at eleven o’clock at night.”

“Fair point.” He picks his scotch back up. “I’ll be in touch.”

He stands. He straightens his jacket. He walks out of the bar without looking back, and I sit very still with my sparkling water and watch him go and feel the cold, precise awareness of a situation that has just become significantly more complicated.

I pay for the water. I take a cab home.

I do not text Samuel tonight.

We must process some information before we can share it.”

-----

I do not sleep.

I lie beside Michael and stare at the ceiling and run the conversation with Matthew Cross through my lawyer’s mind like evidence — sorting, categorizing, identifying what I know versus what I inferred versus what he deliberately withheld.

What I know: He has been watching. Three weeks of specific dates and room numbers. That level of detail is not casual observation. That is documentation.

What I inferred: Someone is paying him. The consulting work with Michael is either genuine or a cover. Either way, he has access, proximity, and six months of who-knows-what.

What he withheld: Everything that actually matters. Who commissioned it? What he intends to do. What is his price — because there is always a price.

Michael shifts beside me. I turn and look at his profile in the dark—handsome, sleeping, completely unaware that a man from his Harvard years just sat across from his wife in a hotel bar and documented her affair for three weeks.

I feel the first real, cold finger of fear move through me.

Not the delicious fear of the beginning — the risk-makes-it-sharper fear that I have been running on since Samuel texted at twelve forty-seven on a Tuesday night. This is different. This is the fear of a woman who has been playing a game and just realized that other people are on the board, and she did not know they were playing.

I get up at five. I make coffee. I sit at the kitchen window, watching the city lighten, and think.

At six fifteen, I texted Samuel.

**Khloe:** *We have a problem. Not Mercy. Someone else. I need to see you today.*

He replies in four minutes. Which means he was already awake.

**Samuel:** *How serious?*

I think about Matthew Cross’s smile. His list of dates and room numbers. His *currently contains.*

**Khloe:** *Serious enough that I almost didn’t text you.*

**Samuel:** *I’ll cancel everything. Come at noon.*

I put the phone down.

Michael walks into the kitchen at six twenty. Suit. Coffee. Phone. The eternal choreography.

“You’re up early,” he says.

“Couldn’t sleep.” True. Completely true.

He glances at me with the distracted warmth of a man who clocks that something is slightly off and files it under *not urgent.* “The estate meeting is at two today. Divine wants you there.”

“I know.” I take a sip of coffee. “I’ll be there.”

He nods. He leaves.

I sit in the silence and think about Matthew Cross and the phrase ‘currently contained,’ and I wonder how long that lasts when someone is being paid to watch you.

-----

Samuel opens the door at noon and reads my face in approximately one second.

“Tell me,” he says. No greeting. No preamble.

I walk in. I sit. I tell him everything — Matthew Cross, the hotel hallway, the bar, the dates and room numbers, the *currently contained*, and the *I’ll be in touch.* I tell it in order, precisely, the way I would brief a colleague on a case.

Samuel listens without interrupting. His face is very still, the way it gets when he is thinking hard beneath a controlled surface. By the time I finish, he is standing at the window with his hands in his pockets, looking at the city, his jaw tight.

“He’s not working for Michael,” he says finally.

“How do you know?”

“Because if Michael knew — even suspected — we would know by now.” He turns. “Michael does not behave quietly when he is angry. He does cold and total. If he knew, you would have come home to locked accounts and a lawyer’s card on the kitchen counter.”

He is right. That is exactly what Michael would do.

“Then who?” I say.

Samuel looks at me steadily. “Divine,” he says.

The word lands like a stone dropped into still water.

Of course. Of course, it is Divine. Divine, who called three times about the estate. Divine, who told me Thomas' wives conduct themselves appropriately. Divine, who has never once believed I was good enough for her son, and has been waiting two years for evidence to support the conclusion she reached at our first handshake.

“She hired him to watch me,” I say.

“To build a case.” Samuel crosses the room and sits beside me. “Not for Michael — for the divorce. She wants you out cleanly. No messy scenes, no he-said-she-said. She wants documentation.”

I sit with that for a moment.

“She doesn’t care about Michael’s feelings,” I say slowly. “She cares about the settlement.

“That’s exactly it.”

I look at Samuel. He looks at me. The full shape of it is clear now — not a jealous assistant or a random witness, but a calculated, months-long operation run by a woman who has been three steps ahead of this since before it started.

“What do we do?” I ask.

Samuel’s eyes are dark and very certain. “We stop being reactive,” he says. “And we get ahead of it.”

“How?”

He opens his mouth to answer.

His phone rings.

He looks at the screen. Something moves through his face — fast and complicated. He looks up at me.

“It’s Michael,” he says.

The air in the room changes entirely.

“Don’t answer,” I say immediately.

“If I don’t answer, he’ll know something is wrong.”

“If you answer with me sitting here—”

“He can’t see you, Khloe.” He holds the phone. It keeps ringing. His eyes stay on mine. “He can’t see you.”

The phone rings.

And rings.

And rings.

Samuel answers.

“Michael.” His voice is completely even. Professional. Not a single thread out of place. “What’s up?”

A pause. I watch Samuel’s face. Watch the thing that happens in his eyes as he listens — something careful and then something that goes very, very still.

He looks at me.

And the look on his face turns my blood to ice.

He says into the phone: “I’ll be there in twenty minutes.”

He hangs up.

“Samuel.” My voice is barely above a whisper. “What did he say?”

Samuel sets the phone down very carefully on the table between us. He looks at me with an expression I have never seen on his face before—not fear exactly, but the look of a man who has just received information that changes the entire shape of what he thought he was dealing with.”

“He found something,” Samuel says quietly. “In the penthouse.” A beat. “Your phone.”

My stomach drops through the floor.

“My phone is in my bag,” I say immediately. “Right here. I have my—”

I open my bag.

My hand finds nothing.

I look down.

My phone is gone.

“Your second phone,” Samuel says. And the way he says it — low, careful, watching my face — tells me that Michael has found something I did not know existed.

Someone put a second phone in my penthouse.

Someone who wanted it to be found.

“Khloe.” Samuel’s hand covers mine on the table. “What was on it?”

I stare at my empty bag.

And realize with absolute, devastating certainty that someone has been playing a much longer game than I ever knew.