Nine-Cup Brew
The first time I find a man's watch in my fiancee Lydia Winslow's car, her father calls me himself to explain it away. "Jonah, you've got the wrong idea about Lydia. That watch is mine. I must have left it there by accident."
The second time, when I discover two movie ticket stubs, her best friend tags me in a group chat. "Don't overthink it. I asked Lydia to buy those tickets for me."
It happens a third time, then a fourth, and every time after that, someone steps forward to cover for her.
By the ninth time, I pull a tie from between the car seats and hold it up in front of her face.
"Whose tie is this?"
Her hand on the steering wheel gives the faintest tremor before she dials a number with practiced ease.
"Someone left a tie in my car. Which one of you is it?"
The call connects to my own sister, Leah Stratton, and my best friend, Bryce Hollander, who also happens to be Leah's husband.
"Lydia? Oh, so that's where it went! No wonder Bryce couldn't find it anywhere. Honestly, though, Jonah, are you doing this again?
"Everyone told you at the last get-together—if you keep picking fights over nothing, you two might as well call off the wedding."
Bryce chimes in right after, saying, "Come on, Jonah. You know how good Lydia is to you. You've been way out of line lately."
After the call ends, Lydia looks at me with wide, innocent eyes.
"Happy now? Can you please stop doubting me? That's nine times now, Jonah. If you do this again, maybe we should just call off the—"
I smile and cut her off.
"You're right. Let's not bother. Cancel the whole thing."
What Lydia doesn't know is that the tie doesn't belong to her lover or to Bryce. I bought it myself and left it in her car on purpose to expose the truth—that every single person around her has been helping cover up her affair.