If you enjoyed 'I Nephi . . .: A Novel of the Sons of Lehi,' you might find 'The Peacegiver' by James L. Ferrell equally compelling. Both books dive deep into themes of faith, family, and personal struggle, though 'The Peacegiver' leans more into allegory and spiritual introspection. Another great pick is 'The Book of Mormon' itself, especially if you're drawn to the historical and religious narrative style. For a more secular but equally immersive experience, 'The Red Tent' by Anita Diamant offers a rich, female-centered perspective on biblical stories, which might resonate if you appreciate the familial and cultural depth in 'I Nephi.'
On the fantasy side, 'The Sword of Shannara' by Terry Brooks has that epic quest vibe mixed with moral dilemmas, though it’s less religious and more action-oriented. Orson Scott Card’s 'The Memory of Earth' is another solid choice, blending sci-fi with religious undertones in a way that might scratch the same itch. Honestly, what I love about these recommendations is how they each capture a slice of what makes 'I Nephi' special—whether it’s the spiritual journey, the family dynamics, or the historical weight. It’s like finding different flavors of the same emotional meal.