Honestly, I was pretty underwhelmed by the summary ratings for 'Remarkably Bright Creatures'. Everyone raves about the 'found family' and 'healing' themes, and while those are there, the summaries make it sound like a much gentler book than it is. A huge theme for me was time—how it weighs on you, how you can waste decades, and the quiet desperation of regret. Marcellus the octopus observing Tova's routine highlights that perfectly. The summaries often reduce it to 'uplifting' which misses the melancholy backbone that made the characters feel real to me.
Maybe it's because I read it after a loss, but the handling of grief, that specific, stubborn, cleaning-at-night-to-avoid-thinking kind of grief, was the standout. The ratings mention grief, but they don't capture how the book lets it be messy and unresolved for so long. The 'mystery' plot gets highlighted more, but the emotional core is slower, stickier. I think the high ratings come from that balance, but the summaries sometimes favor the quirk over the quiet ache.