Question 1

What's the main plot twist in they're going to love you?

Accepted Answer

Okay, so the big twist in Meg Howrey's 'They’re Going to Love You'... it sneaks up on you, I think. The whole book builds on this idyllic, almost mythical image of Carlisle's summers with her father Robert and his partner James at their Greenwich Village apartment. You're led to believe the central rupture in the family, the reason Carlisle and Robert are estranged for decades, is about some artistic betrayal or career jealousy.

But it's much smaller and more devastating. The twist is that Carlisle, as a teenager desperate to be seen as a 'real' dancer and part of their world, inadvertently revealed James's HIV-positive status to a family friend, breaking a sacred confidence. The fallout wasn't from a grand act of malice, but from a childish, clumsy moment of wanting to feel important, which had irreversible consequences in the height of the AIDS crisis. It reframes the entire memory of that artistic haven—it was also a place of profound, unspoken fear and love fiercely protecting its own.

What gutted me was realizing the ‘crime’ wasn't theatrical; it was a quiet, human mistake that cost her everything.

Question 2

Is they're going to love you based on a true story?

Accepted Answer

That title always throws people. It’s not based on a specific, documented true story like a memoir or a historical event. It feels real because Leesa Cross-Smith writes families and messy relationships with such visceral, lived-in detail—the jealousy, the quiet betrayals, the way love and resentment tangle over decades. She captures the texture of real life, so it resonates as truth even if the plot isn't ripped from headlines.

I think the confusion comes from how grounded it is. There's no grand, melodramatic twist; it’s about a ballet dancer returning to her Kentucky hometown, navigating the fallout of her mother’s affair with her uncle’s wife. The emotional logic—the silences, the half-spoken things—feels painfully accurate. So while it’s fiction, it’s built from true emotional raw materials. The ending, especially, has that messy, unresolved quality real life often has.

Question 3

Who are the key characters in they're going to love you?

Accepted Answer

First things first, it's all about Carlisle. The book, 'They're Going to Love You', is very much her story. We follow her from a child obsessed with ballet, visiting her father Robert and his partner James in their Greenwich Village apartment, right through to her adult life as a choreographer. Her relationship with those two men, especially with her father, is the absolute heart of the novel. It's a quiet, precise kind of story about art, family secrets, and the grief that comes from long-held silences.

Robert and James are the other pillars. They're this elegant, seemingly perfect couple who create a magical world for young Carlisle. Robert is the intellectual, the writer, a bit more distant. James, a former dancer, is the warmer, more nurturing presence. The dynamic between them, and how Carlisle fits into it, shapes everything. The central conflict, the betrayal that fractures the family for decades, revolves entirely around a moment between Carlisle and these two men. I found myself going back over their early scenes, looking for hints of what was to come.

Honestly, I wish we'd gotten a bit more from James's perspective at times. He felt like the emotional core of that household, but the narrative is so tightly bound to Carlisle's point of view that some of his interiority remains just out of reach. That's probably intentional, though, mirroring how we can never fully know everything about the people we love.

Question 4

Where can I listen to the audiobook of they're going to love you?

Accepted Answer

I actually found the audiobook on Libro.fm! It’s a good alternative if you’re trying to avoid that one massive retailer. The narration by Kristen Sieh is really solid—she captures Carlisle’s mix of anxiety and artistic longing perfectly, which is a huge part of the book’s vibe. It’s not just about listening; her performance adds a layer of interiority to the ballet world and family drama that I appreciated.

One thing to note: I checked my local library’s app (Hoopla) first, but they only had the ebook. Might be worth trying OverDrive or Libby depending on your library system. If you’re into contemporary fiction about messy creative families, this audiobook definitely works. The quiet moments in the Chelsea apartment felt even more intimate with headphones on.

They're Going To Love You Novels & Stories

KILLER

Divorced while pregnant: His regret came too late

You are my endless love.

Chained to the Mafia King Xaphan

PREGNANT AND BANISHED

The Worthless Ex-Wife's Revenge

ALPHA VS ALPHA

FATED TO MY UNCLE

My love towards you

The Vampire King's Obsession