Looking for that iconic FNAF Bonnie hand puppet feels like tracking down a rare collectible! I scoured Etsy first—tons of indie creators make handmade versions with crazy attention to detail, like glow-in-the- eyes or articulated jaws. Prices vary wildly though; some are $30, others hit $200 for premium materials.
Amazon’s got mass-produced ones, but reviews mention flimsy stitching, so I’d cross-check with eBay for retired official merch. Saw a sealed 2015 McFarlane Toys Bonnie puppet there last week, but bidding wars got intense. Pro move: join FNAF Facebook collector groups—members often resell at fair prices before scalpers grab them.