When We Believed In Mermaids Novels & Stories

The twist in 'When We Believed in Mermaids' completely flips your understanding of the story. Josie, presumed dead for years, is actually alive and living under a new identity in New Zealand. Her sister Kit spots her in a news clip from a disaster, sparking a journey to uncover the truth. The real shocker is why Josie faked her death—escaping a traumatic past filled with abuse and a life she couldn’t bear anymore. The revelation that she chose to abandon her family to protect them from her own demons adds layers to her character. It’s not just about survival; it’s about the painful choices people make to find peace. The twist forces you to rethink every interaction and memory shared between the sisters, making the emotional payoff intense.

I recently finished 'When We Believed in Mermaids', and the sisters' dynamic is one of the most compelling parts of the story. Kit and Josie Bianci are sisters who grew up in a chaotic, bohemian household in California, but their lives take drastically different paths after a tragedy. Kit, the younger sister, becomes an ER doctor in New Zealand, living a structured life that contrasts sharply with her wild childhood. Josie, the older sister, is presumed dead after a terrorist attack in Europe—until Kit spots her on TV years later. This discovery sends Kit on a journey to uncover the truth about her sister's disappearance and the secrets that fractured their family.

What makes their relationship so fascinating is how differently they cope with trauma. Kit buries herself in work and logic, while Josie reinvents herself entirely, slipping into a new identity. The novel explores how memory can be unreliable, especially when shaped by loss. Josie’s transformation into someone else isn’t just about survival; it’s a rebellion against the past. The contrast between Kit’s steadfastness and Josie’s fluid identity creates this tension that drives the narrative. The sisters’ bond is messy, painful, and deeply real, showing how family ties can both haunt and heal.

The novel 'When We Believed in Mermaids' is primarily set in two stunning coastal locations that contrast beautifully. Most of the present-day action unfolds in Auckland, New Zealand, where the protagonist Kit lives as an ER doctor. The author paints vivid pictures of the city's harbor and black sand beaches, making the setting almost a character itself. The story also flashes back to their childhood in California, specifically the fictional seaside town of Echo Bay. These coastal settings mirror the sisters' turbulent relationship with water - both as a source of joy during their childhood and as the site of their greatest tragedy. The New Zealand sections particularly shine with descriptions of volcanic landscapes and Maori cultural elements woven into the narrative.