ห้องสมุด

ค้นหา

Why Is Fyodor Dostoevsky The Possessed Controversial?

2025-06-03 08:54:50 105

3 answers

Quinn

2025-06-04 04:12:21

I've always been fascinated by how 'The Possessed' (also known as 'Demons') sparks such heated debates. Dostoevsky didn’t just write a novel; he ripped straight from the political and social chaos of 19th-century Russia. The book’s portrayal of radical ideologies and the destruction they bring was so raw that it felt like a slap to both conservatives and revolutionaries. Some critics argue it’s overly pessimistic, painting revolutionaries as fanatics without nuance. Others, like me, see it as a prophetic warning—almost like Dostoevsky peered into the future and saw the Bolshevik Revolution coming. The graphic violence, like Shatov’s murder, and the unflinching critique of nihilism made it a lightning rod for controversy. Even today, it divides readers who either hail it as a masterpiece or dismiss it as reactionary fearmongering.

Zoe

2025-06-09 05:51:40

Dostoevsky’s 'The Possessed' is a literary grenade, and here’s why it still detonates in modern discussions. The novel’s exploration of radicalism isn’t just historical; it feels eerily relevant. Dostoevsky based characters like Pyotr Verkhovensky on real anarchists, exposing the dangerous allure of ideology over humanity. The book’s critics often accuse it of being a one-sided rant against leftist movements, but that misses the point. It’s less about politics and more about the moral decay when people worship ideas instead of people. The character Stavrogin, with his chilling apathy and descent into madness, embodies this perfectly.

Then there’s the religious angle. Dostoevsky, a devout Orthodox Christian, wove his faith into the narrative like a counterweight to nihilism. The controversial 'Stavrogin’s Confession' chapter (censored in early editions) delves into themes of guilt and redemption so dark that even Tolstoy called it 'painful.' Yet, this brutality is what makes the book unforgettable. It’s not just a critique of revolutionaries—it’s a mirror held up to any society flirting with ideological extremism. Whether you love or hate it, 'The Possessed' forces you to confront uncomfortable truths about human nature.

Noah

2025-06-08 01:45:17

As someone who devours Russian literature, 'The Possessed' stands out for its sheer audacity. Dostoevsky didn’t shy away from depicting the ugliest sides of human psychology, and that’s why it’s so polarizing. Take the character Kirillov, who believes suicide is the ultimate act of free will—it’s philosophical dynamite. The novel’s backlash wasn’t just about politics; it was about Dostoevsky’s refusal to offer easy answers. Unlike 'Crime and Punishment,' where Raskolnikov finds redemption, 'The Possessed' leaves you drowning in ambiguity.

The censorship history adds another layer. The original version included scenes so dark (like Stavrogin’s abuse of a child) that publishers chopped them out. Modern editions restored these passages, reigniting debates about whether they’re profound or gratuitous. For me, that’s Dostoevsky’s genius—he forces readers to grapple with discomfort. The book’s reception split along ideological lines: conservatives praised its warning against chaos, while radicals called it a caricature. Yet its portrayal of how ideas can possess people like demons feels timeless, especially in today’s polarized world.

ดูคำตอบทั้งหมด

Related Books

The Deviant CEO

Alex Black has always known she was different in some strange way, She was never interested in boys her own age. She knows she wants an older man and she knows exactly who she wants. Problem is, Who she wants is her father's best friend who just so happens to be her new boss, Roman Lewis. They've already hooked up a few times, but when things get serious, Can Alex rely on Roman?... or will all just be proved too much?

9.6

82 Chapters

Chosen By The Moon

This book is authored by izabella W. "Mate!" My eyes bulged out of my head as I snapped up to regard the guy who is obviously the king. His eyes were locked on mine as he began to advance very quickly. Oh great. That's why he looked familiar, he was the same guy who I bumped into only an hour or two before hand. The one who claimed I was his mate... Oh... SHIT! *** In a dystopian future, it is the 5-year anniversary of the end of the earth as we knew it. A race of supernatural creatures calling themselves the lycanthrope has taken over and nothing has been the same. Every town is split into two districts, the human district, and the wolf district. The humans are now treated as a minority, while the Lycans are to be treated with the utmost respect, failure to submit to them results in brutal public punishments. For Dylan, a 17-year-old girl, living in this new world is tough. Being 12 when the wolves took over, she has both witnessed and experienced public punishment firsthand. Wolves have been domineering since the new world and if you're found to be the mate of one, for Dylan it is a fate worse than death. So what happens when she finds out she not only is a lycan’s mate but that lycan happens to be the most famous and the most brutal of them all? Follow Dylan on her rocky journey, combatting life, love, and loss. A new spin on the typical wolf story. I hope you enjoy it. Warning, mature content. Scenes of strong Abuse. Scenes of self-harm Scenes of Rape. Scenes of a Sexually explicit nature. READ AT YOUR OWN RISK.

8.7

447 Chapters

The Venerable Swordsman

As the heir apparent of the Ye family, Ye Xuan went through fire and water for his family, but Ye Lang, who had just awakened his Divine Soul, usurped his place. In order to keep his position, Ye Xuan challenged Ye Lang to a Life-death Duel. With the broken Dantian, would he win this fight? The black ring his mother left brought him a great opportunity: Realm Hell Tower, where he met a mysterious lady, who told him to look for nine Daoist Laws to enhance his strength and gave him the Spirit Heaven Sword. Could Ye Xuan find all the Daoist Laws and become a powerful swordsman?

9.7

2049 Chapters

Mr. Ford Is Jealous

As they stood atop a cliff, the kidnapper held a knife to her throat, and the throat of his dream girl. “You can choose only one.”“I choose her,” the man said, pointing to his dream girl.Stella’s voice trembled as she said, “Weston… I’m pregnant.”Weston looked at her indifferently. “Gwen has a fear of heights.”Many years passed after that.Rumor had it that Ahn City’s prestigious Mr. Weston Ford was always lingering outside the house of his ex-wife, even breaking boundaries to pamper her, even if she would never bat an eyelid at him.Rumor had it that the night Stella brought a man home with her, Weston almost died at her door. Everyone was envious of Stella, but she smiled politely and said, “Don’t die at my door. I fear germs.”

8.8

1435 Chapters

BURNING PASSION: MY FORBIDDEN LOVER

Eighteen years old Marilyn Muriel is shocked on one beautiful summer by her mom when she brings in a strikingly, handsome young man and introduces him as her new husband. An instant unexplainable connection is formed between her and this Greek god as he secretly begins to cast various unwanted signals towards her. Marilyn soon finds herself going through various, irresistible sexual escapades with this charming, seductive fellow in the absence of her mom. What will be the fate or outcome of such an act and will her mom ever get to know the atrocity going on right under her nose?

9.6

115 Chapters

Alpha Nocturne's Contracted Mate

“Fuck, Ada…”“Brad...oh, fuck... deeper... harder!” Ada’s shrill voice begged between breathy moans.The banging of the headboard against the wall intensified as Ann froze. No... it couldn’t be!Ann took a deep breath and nudged the door a little more. Her chest felt like it would explode as she held her breath whilst the crack widened.When it revealed her sister lying underneath her husband-to-be, her hands flew to her mouth to stifle the gasp of horror as her heart shattered instantly.As Brad roared his release inside her sister, Ada turned her head towards the door with a smirk.An icy chill descended over Ann as if a bucket of ice water had been thrown over her and she stood and stared, her eyes wide and mouth slightly open in disbelief.Ada lifted her hand and waved in Ada’s direction with a smug smile plastered on her face as Brad collapsed on top of her, kissing her neck tenderly.Is there anything you can do if your mate had sex with your sister?

9.7

302 Chapters

Related Questions

What Genre Is The Possessed Fyodor Dostoevsky?

4 answers2025-06-03 17:50:29

I've always been fascinated by how 'The Possessed' (also known as 'Demons') by Fyodor Dostoevsky defies simple genre categorization. At its core, it’s a psychological and philosophical novel, diving deep into the human psyche and the chaos of revolutionary ideals. The book blends elements of political satire, dark humor, and tragedy, painting a grim picture of 19th-century Russian society. What stands out is how Dostoevsky merges crime thriller pacing with existential dread, making it a precursor to modern dystopian fiction. The characters are layered, their motivations twisted by ideology and madness, which adds a Gothic horror undertone. It’s not just a novel; it’s a mirror held up to the extremes of human nature, wrapped in a narrative that feels eerily prophetic.

What Is The Plot Of The Possessed By Fyodor Dostoevsky?

4 answers2025-06-03 09:33:19

As someone deeply immersed in Russian literature, I find 'The Possessed' (also known as 'Demons') by Fyodor Dostoevsky to be a gripping exploration of nihilism and revolutionary fervor. The novel centers around a group of radical intellectuals in a provincial Russian town, led by the enigmatic Pyotr Verkhovensky, who aims to overthrow societal order. The plot unfolds through a series of scandals, murders, and ideological clashes, revealing the destructive power of unchecked extremism. At its core, the story critiques the moral decay and chaos bred by radical ideas, embodied by characters like Nikolai Stavrogin, a charismatic but morally bankrupt aristocrat. The novel’s tension builds as the group’s plans spiral into violence, culminating in tragic consequences. Dostoevsky’s sharp psychological insight and dense narrative make it a challenging yet rewarding read, reflecting his fears about the rising revolutionary movements in 19th-century Russia.

When Was Fyodor Dostoevsky The Possessed Written?

3 answers2025-06-03 19:58:55

I remember reading 'The Possessed' a while back and being completely absorbed by its intense political and psychological themes. Fyodor Dostoevsky wrote this masterpiece between 1871 and 1872. It was serialized in the journal 'The Russian Messenger' before being published as a complete novel in 1872. The book is also known as 'Demons' in some translations, but the original Russian title is 'Бесы' (Besy). I was particularly struck by how Dostoevsky used the story to critique the radical ideologies of his time, and the characters are some of the most complex I've ever encountered in literature. The novel's exploration of nihilism and revolutionary fervor feels eerily relevant even today.

Who Are The Main Characters In The Possessed Fyodor Dostoevsky?

4 answers2025-06-03 00:20:59

As someone deeply immersed in classic literature, I find the characters in 'The Possessed' (also known as 'Demons') by Fyodor Dostoevsky utterly fascinating. The novel revolves around a chaotic Russian town where ideological extremism spirals out of control. The central figure is Nikolai Stavrogin, a charismatic but morally bankrupt aristocrat whose enigmatic presence fuels the narrative. His cold, detached demeanor masks a soul tormented by nihilism and guilt, particularly after his scandalous interactions with Shatov’s wife and the young Matryosha. Another pivotal character is Pyotr Verkhovensky, a manipulative revolutionary who orchestrates much of the chaos. His cunning and ruthlessness contrast sharply with the idealistic but naive Shatov, who represents Slavophile values. Kirillov, a man obsessed with the idea of voluntary suicide to prove human freedom, adds a philosophical layer to the story. Meanwhile, Stepan Trofimovich, Pyotr’s father, embodies the ineffectual liberal intellectuals of Dostoevsky’s time. These characters intertwine to create a devastating critique of radical ideologies and human nature.

Are There Any Movies Based On The Possessed Fyodor Dostoevsky?

4 answers2025-06-03 22:20:39

As someone deeply immersed in both literature and film adaptations, I can confidently say that Fyodor Dostoevsky’s novel 'The Possessed' (also known as 'Demons') hasn’t received as many cinematic treatments as some of his other works like 'Crime and Punishment' or 'The Idiot'. However, there are a few notable adaptations worth exploring. The 1958 French film 'Les Possédés', directed by Andrzej Wajda, is one of the most prominent, capturing the novel’s intense political and psychological turmoil. It’s a black-and-white masterpiece that stays true to Dostoevsky’s dark themes. Another adaptation is the 1992 Russian TV movie 'Besy', which delves into the novel’s chaotic narrative with a more modern lens. While not as widely known, it offers a raw, unfiltered take on the story. For those who appreciate experimental cinema, the 1988 film 'The Devils' by Andrzej Żuławski, though loosely inspired, channels the novel’s anarchic spirit. If you’re a Dostoevsky fan, these adaptations are fascinating but don’t expect them to replace the depth of the original text.

Who Published The Possessed Fyodor Dostoevsky Originally?

4 answers2025-06-03 06:08:15

As an avid reader of classic literature, I’ve always been fascinated by Dostoevsky’s works, especially 'The Possessed' (also known as 'Demons'). The novel was originally published in serial form in the Russian journal 'The Russian Messenger' between 1871 and 1872. It was later released as a complete book in 1872. Dostoevsky’s publisher for this work was the prominent Russian printing house 'The Russian Messenger,' which was known for serializing many of his other major novels, including 'Crime and Punishment' and 'The Brothers Karamazov.' The serial format allowed Dostoevsky to refine the story based on reader feedback, which was common at the time. The novel’s exploration of political radicalism and psychological depth makes it a standout in his bibliography. Interestingly, 'The Possessed' was inspired by real-life events, particularly the Nechayev affair, which involved a radical revolutionary group. Dostoevsky’s ability to weave historical context into his fiction is part of what makes his work so enduring. The book’s initial reception was mixed, but it has since gained critical acclaim as one of his most complex and politically charged novels.

Who Published Fyodor Dostoevsky The Possessed First?

2 answers2025-06-03 14:54:56

I've always been fascinated by the history behind classic literature, especially when it comes to controversial works like 'The Possessed'. Dostoevsky's novel first saw the light of day in 1872, serialized in 'The Russian Messenger', a major literary and political journal of the time. It's wild to think how different the publishing landscape was back then—no instant ebooks or viral tweets, just slow, deliberate serialization that let the story simmer in readers' minds. The editor, Mikhail Katkov, was a polarizing figure himself, known for his conservative views. His influence on Dostoevsky's work adds another layer to the novel's explosive themes of ideology and revolution. What's really gripping is how the novel evolved during serialization. Dostoevsky, ever the perfectionist, made significant revisions before the standalone book version dropped in 1873. The original journal version had passages toned down due to censorship fears, yet still managed to provoke fierce debates. Tracking down early editions feels like detective work—some print runs are incredibly rare now, with subtle variations that drive collectors nuts. The novel's journey from serial to book mirrors its own chaotic narrative, a perfect storm of artistic vision and 19th-century publishing realities.

What Is The Main Plot Of Fyodor Dostoevsky The Possessed?

2 answers2025-06-03 13:23:30

I've always been fascinated by how 'The Possessed' (or 'Demons') isn't just a novel—it's a psychological earthquake. The story follows a group of radicals in a provincial Russian town, led by the charismatic but dangerous Pyotr Verkhovensky. Think of him as a cult leader mixed with a political agitator, manipulating everyone like chess pieces. The real tragedy centers around Nikolai Stavrogin, this aristocratic enigma whose emptiness and moral decay infect everyone around him. Dostoevsky doesn't just write characters; he dissects them, showing how ideology without humanity turns into pure destruction. What grips me most is the sheer chaos. There's murder, suicide, and even arson—all spiraling from Pyotr's twisted vision of revolution. But it's not just about politics; it's about the void inside people. Kirillov's obsession with suicide to 'prove' his freedom, Shatov's desperate search for meaning—these aren't just subplots. They're nightmares dressed as philosophy. The climax at the fire feels like watching a train wreck in slow motion, with every character's fate crashing together in this terrifying symphony of doom.

Why Is Fyodor Dostoevsky The Possessed Controversial?

3 answers

Related Books

Related Questions

What Genre Is The Possessed Fyodor Dostoevsky?

What Is The Plot Of The Possessed By Fyodor Dostoevsky?

When Was Fyodor Dostoevsky The Possessed Written?

Who Are The Main Characters In The Possessed Fyodor Dostoevsky?

Are There Any Movies Based On The Possessed Fyodor Dostoevsky?

Who Published The Possessed Fyodor Dostoevsky Originally?

Who Published Fyodor Dostoevsky The Possessed First?

What Is The Main Plot Of Fyodor Dostoevsky The Possessed?

Popular Question

Are Lib Ebooks Available In Multiple Languages And Formats?

Why Did Antonio Leave Chicago Pd

How Tall Is Toph

How To Download Free Pdf Of Books From Publishers?

Are Books For The Nook Available In Audiobook Format?

What Is Agent 00 Real Name

Why Is 'The Night Swim' So Popular?

Are There Any Trigger Warnings For 'Futa Slave'?

How Many Chapters Does 5 Love Book Have?

Where Can I Buy 'Journey To Topaz' Online?

Popular Searches More