Andrew's Pov
I sat in my office at the far end of the gym, the summer heat getting worse by each passing second. My clipboard was on the desk, the names of all the players carefully written on it.
I was supposed to be planning strategies for the team, setting rotations, but instead, my eyes kept drifting to her name Sage Davis.
There were unspoken rules, but as solid as concrete.
Rule one: you never get involved with anyone on the team. Your job is to teach, nothing more.
Rule two: you sure as hell don't let your eyes linger on your daughter's best friend.
But yet here I was, breaking all of them.
I'd heard so much about her from Pauline
how Sage was the golden girl, the fast-rising star. But in only just a few seconds of glory, she blew everything with a selfish move.
Pauline cried so much, saying everyone had turned on Sage, and she disappeared, ghosting her for months.
But when I saw her, when I got to know the real her, she surprised me.
I could see she still carried the weight of her selfish actions, and the guilt is eating deeper and deeper into her.
She was scared.
But willing to come back after everything made her brave.
I leaned back in my chair, letting out a heavy breath. She was my daughter's best friend, my player, and also my responsibility. And yet that morning, when she nailed that shot, the way she smiled at me felt like an unexplainable pull.
~~~~
By the time afternoon practice began, I had my coach face back on, whistle around my neck, clipboard in hand.
Sage walked into the gym, she and Pauline laughing at something. The smile on her face was so real, and for that moment I couldn't see the worry.
I immediately started organizing drills. I couldn't afford to notice things like that. It wasn't right.
I separated the teams into pairs for defensive footwork. Rina rolled her eyes, annoyance clear on her face when I partnered her up with Sage, but she didn't say anything.
I kept them moving fast, eyes concentrated, body moving sharp with shuffle steps and pivot turns.
“Move those feet faster, Davis, let's go!"
She responded well to instructions, never complained for once. She needed sharpening and not pampering, and that's exactly what I'll do.
I could see the tension building between her and Rina. Rina looked for every opportunity to bump into Sage, but Sage didn't say a word. She clenched her fists while Rina had a smirk on her face.
Sage jogged off, sweat running down her face. She caught my eye for less than a second before she looked away.
Later, after all the players had left, I found myself standing in the empty court staring at nothing, old habits, I guess.
When you've been a basketball coach for as long as I have, the silence after practice becomes part of you.
Suddenly, I heard footsteps echo through the gym, hesitant and slow.
When I turned around, she was there, Sage.
She stood there, backpack strapped on her back, face a little pale.
"Everyone's gone," she said.
"I know... just needed a minute," I replied.
She gave a slight nod. I immediately turned my attention to the clipboard, pretending to take notes.
"Do you ever regret coaching again?"
I looked at her thoughtfully for a minute before answering. "Sometimes, but not for the reasons you'd think."
She slowly walked back into the court. Her hand grazed the court rack, but she didn't take any, just touched it lightly.
"I feel like I'm drowning half the time, like everyone is just waiting for me to mess up again," she said, her voice low.
"You are not alone in that."
I smiled faintly. “My career in the league ended earlier than I wanted. My marriage… well, you know.”
"I used to think I was invisible and unstoppable," she said, "but now I just want to disappear, to hide and pretend none of this is real."
"Sage, do you want to know the difference between a prodigy and a failure?"
"What?"
"Resilience."
"Think about it for a moment. You are still here after everything that happened. Yeah, you messed up, but you're trying to make amends. That's what matters, not the mistakes."
For a long moment, we just stared at each other without a word.
She was so close I could see the scar on her jaw, the shape of her mouth. I should have walked away, but I didn't. I stood there.
"I don't want to mess up again," she admitted.
I reached up, touching a loose hair behind her ear. Her lips parted. "You won't. I'll make sure of that. Go get some rest, Davis. You have a long season ahead."
She walked away. My heart pounding in my chest. I had just crossed a line I was never supposed to.
~~~~
That night, I couldn't sleep.
I tried everything: baking, music, late-night movies but nothing was working.
My phone buzzed around midnight.
Pauline: Dad, can you please come pick me up from Gabby's? Her car just died.
I immediately threw on a hoodie and grabbed my keys.
Within twenty minutes, I pulled into the driveway. Pauline hopped into the front seat, tossing her backpack to the back.
"You okay?" I asked.
"Yeah, just tired. Gabby's mom talks way too much."
Pauline leaned her head back. "Sage has been off lately."
My grip on the wheel tightened.
"She must be going through a lot," I said.
"She's always going through a lot, but it feels different. She’s just been so distant."
I stayed quiet.
"Maybe she doesn't want to bother you with her problems," I finally said.
"She's my best friend, Dad. I don't care if she bothers me."
"She doesn't like to talk about what happened, but I know it's still hurting her."
Pauline looked so sad.
I glanced at my daughter. She had no idea how complicated things really were.
"She's still figuring things out," I said.
"Aren't we all?" she mumbled before drifting off to sleep.
When I pulled into the driveway, I didn’t move for a long time.
I sat in the car and stared at the steering wheel, knowing full well that I was headed into dangerous territory.
Because this wasn’t just a coach and player.
This wasn’t just an age gap.
This was my daughter’s best friend.
And whatever was growing between us it wasn’t slowing down.
Sage PovI looked up, meeting his gaze. His expression remained stoic but I could see a flash of something in his eyes, something akin to disappointment.“I know it sounds crazy,” I continued, my voice pleading, “but I really thought it was the best way. Pauline was starting to doubt me and I couldn’t bear the thought of her thinking… of her thinking anything bad about you or about us.”He listened in silence, his expression unwavering. I rushed to explain further, to justify my actions. “And I almost, almost said yes to Kay when he asked me to be his girlfriend. It would have solidified the story for Pauline, made Rina’s accusations completely irrelevant. But I didn’t. I couldn’t. Because I value what we have, Andrew. I value you. I couldn’t betray that even for a plan.”I watched him, desperate for a sign of understanding of forgiveness. But instead, Andrew slowly shook his head, a faint, humorless smile touching his lips.“Sage,” he said, his voice soft, almost a whisper, but it cu
Sage's POV The next morning, the lingering unease from the night before clung to me like a damp cloth. Sleep hadn't offered much respite and I woke feeling more exhausted than when I'd gone to bed. The thought of facing Pauline and then Andrew, knowing the web of half-truths I'd woven, made my stomach churn. I dragged myself out of bed, each movement feeling heavy.At school, Pauline was waiting for me by my locker, her eyes sparkling with anticipation. “So? How was it? Tell me everything!” she gushed, practically bouncing on the balls of her feet.I forced a smile, trying to conjure up an air of casual excitement. “It was good, really good,” I began, choosing my words carefully. “Kay’s really sweet. We went for a picnic at the park and then we grabbed dinner at that new Italian place.”Pauline’s eyes widened. “Oh my god, the Italian place? I heard it’s amazing! What did you guys talk about? Did he hold your hand? Did he try to kiss you?” Her questions came in a rapid-fire succession
Sage's POV The atmosphere shifted subtly after that. We finished packing up the picnic, the easy camaraderie replaced by a quiet tension. Kay still tried to make conversation but I felt a wall go up between us, a direct consequence of my indecision.As we drove back towards town, Kay suggested, “Do you want to grab some dinner? We could go to that new Italian place everyone’s talking about.”My heart sank. More time with Kay, more opportunities for him to press me, more chances for me to dig myself deeper into this lie. But refusing would be suspicious, especially after my earlier "date" excuse to Pauline.“Sure, Kay,” I said, forcing a smile. “That sounds great.”The Italian restaurant was bustling. We were seated at a small table near the window. The aroma of garlic and tomato filled the air but my appetite was gone. I picked at my pasta, my mind replaying Kay’s question.Kay, sensing my distraction, tried to lighten the mood. He told me a funny story about a disastrous basketball
Ava's POV The rest of the school day passed in a blur of Pauline’s excited whispers and my own internal monologue of guilt and relief. She peppered me with questions about Kay and I fabricated details, weaving a convincing narrative of a budding romance. It felt sickeningly easy, and that only amplified my unease. I was using Kay and I was lying to Pauline, two things I genuinely dislike doing. But the alternative – Rina successfully poisoning Pauline’s mind was far worse.As the final bell rang, I found myself walking out of school with Pauline, her arm linked through mine, her earlier suspicions seemingly forgotten. “You have to tell me everything about your date with Kay tonight,” she gushed, squeezing my arm. “Every single detail! And you know what? We should totally have a double date sometime! Me and… well, I’ll find someone and you and Kay!”I offered a weak smile, the thought of a double date with Kay and Pauline filling me with dread. “Yeah, maybe,” I mumbled, trying to soun
Sage's POV I sighed, running a hand through my hair. “I know she doesn’t have real evidence. She’s just trying to break my friendship with Pauline. If Pauline goes to meet her, it means she doesn’t trust me. And if I try to stop her, it’ll only confirm the truth—that I am, in fact, having a relationship with her best friend’s father.” I looked at him, my gaze unwavering. “It’s a test of our friendship, Andrew.”His brow furrowed, a deep frown settling between his eyes. “Do you need help, Sage? I could talk to Pauline myself. That way, she wouldn’t suspect anything from your end.”I shook my head. “No. I can handle this. I knew what I signed up for the moment I started seeing you. And if Rina truly has evidence and Pauline chooses to believe her… then I’ll accept my fate.” I paused then looked up at him, a question in my eyes. “What would you do, Andrew, if Pauline discovered the truth?”His hand tightened around mine. His eyes held a fierce resolve. “I honestly don’t care, Sage. The
Sage's POV I swallowed hard, forcing my expression into one of calm indifference. “Pauline,” I said, my voice steady despite the frantic pounding of my heart, “I need to head to the library for work. Are you coming or do you have somewhere else to be?”Pauline, still fuming but momentarily distracted, nodded. “No, I’ll come with you.”Rina, overhearing, let out another sneering laugh. “Look at her, Pauline! Running away already! She’s just scared, isn’t she?”This time, Pauline’s response was swift and sharp. She spun around, her eyes blazing. “You know what, Rina? You're shameless. Stop acting like a bitch.” Before Rina could retort, Pauline grabbed my hand and her grip surprisingly firmly and tugged me away. “Come on, Sage. Let’s go.”We walked out of the school, leaving Rina and her coven of gossips in our wake. The fresh air outside was a welcome relief even if the tension in my shoulders remained. I drove to the local library, my mind a whirl of Rina’s threat and Anastasia’s chi