I was trying to explain this exact vibe to a friend the other day. McCarthy's voice is so distinct, but a few others carve out that same stark, brutal landscape with sentences that hit like stones. Paul Harding in 'Tinkers' comes to mind immediately—the prose is just devastatingly beautiful and sparse, focused on the interior life of a dying man. It has that same weight, that feeling of every word being essential and placed with absolute care. Another one is Denis Johnson, especially in 'Jesus' Son'. The sentences are short, often fragmented, and they carry this weird, luminous poetry even when describing absolute squalor. It’s less about the epic western scope and more about fractured, intimate desperation, but the linguistic precision is similar.
Robinson's 'Gilead' trilogy, while thematically different with its gentle, pastoral setting, shares that profound deliberateness. Each sentence feels unearthed, not written. She and McCarthy are like two sides of the same coin: one gazing into a terrible, godless abyss, the other into a quiet, grace-filled light, but both using language with a kind of sacred thrift. For a different angle, I’d say James Salter. His work, like 'Light Years', is obsessed with the perfect, crystalline phrase. It’s more cosmopolitan than McCarthy, concerned with beauty and loss among the privileged, but the prose is equally pared-back, poetic, and utterly unforgiving in its clarity. You don’t read him for plot; you read him for the sheer, arresting impact of a perfectly crafted observation. That’s the throughline, I think—authors who make you stop, reread a line, and feel the silence around it.