Not in Our Stars
Oscar Miller was Shirley Bishop's personal bodyguard, but when she got attacked on her birthday, he shielded her foster sister, Myra Bishop, with his own body.
Shirley got cut three times—once across her face, once on her arm, and a third that stabbed her lower abdomen, leaving her unable to have children ever again.
But even after all that, she still wanted to marry him.
Later, Oscar did marry her—but he never touched her, not even once, all the way until his death.
At his funeral, the insurance company showed up.
"Mr. Miller purchased a large insurance policy before his death. The beneficiary is Ms. Myra Bishop."
That was when Shirley realized that after all these years, Oscar had never gotten over Myra.
Now, she had been reborn to when her father asked her to choose from four men she had grown up with to be her husband. This time, she decided to fulfill his wish and picked someone else.