How Does 'Guns, Germs, And Steel' Explain Eurasia'S Dominance?

2025-06-20 23:41:10 90

4 answers

Hannah
Hannah
2025-06-24 18:16:54
In 'Guns, Germs, and Steel,' Jared Diamond argues Eurasia's dominance wasn’t about racial superiority but geography and luck. The continent’s east-west axis allowed crops and animals to spread easily, unlike the Americas or Africa, where climate zones varied drastically. This led to surplus food, dense populations, and complex societies. Eurasia also had more domesticable species—think wheat, horses—which fueled agriculture and warfare.

Diamond highlights steel and guns as byproducts of these advantages. Dense societies competed fiercely, driving innovation in weapons and governance. Germs played a cruel role: Eurasians, living near livestock for millennia, developed immunity to diseases that later decimated other continents. It’s a story of environmental head starts, not innate brilliance.
Mila
Mila
2025-06-22 01:45:37
The book flips the script on history—Eurasia didn’t conquer because it was smarter but because it won the geographic lottery. Fertile Crescent crops like barley spread rapidly along similar latitudes, while Australia’s isolation left it stranded. Domesticated animals, rare elsewhere, gave Eurasians plows, manure, and eventually, cavalry. Dense populations meant more inventors, more armies, more trade networks. When Europeans sailed out, they carried guns forged in competitive states and germs honed in crowded cities. Diamond’s take is humbling: dominance was an accident of maps and microbes.
Yara
Yara
2025-06-26 18:39:04
Diamond’s thesis boils down to three advantages: geography, biology, and disease. Eurasia’s sprawling landmass hosted diverse but interconnected climates, letting farming techniques diffuse quickly. Animals like cows and sheep weren’t just food but labor and war machines. Meanwhile, germs from livestock jumpstarted pandemics that devastated others. The book’s strength is showing how steel and guns were late-game perks—Eurasia’s real edge started with wheat fields and chicken coops millennia earlier.
Julia
Julia
2025-06-24 12:02:04
'Guns, Germs, and Steel' credits Eurasia’s dominance to early agricultural luck. Where other continents struggled with sparse domesticable plants or animals, Eurasia thrived. More food meant more people, which meant more innovation—and more deadly germs. By the time empires clashed, Eurasia had stacked advantages: technology from surplus labor, armies fed by farms, and diseases that acted as unwitting biological weapons. Diamond makes it clear: history’s winners weren’t destined; they just rolled better dice.
모든 답변 보기
QR 코드를 스캔하여 앱을 다운로드하세요

Related Books

길에서 주운 노숙자가 알고보니 유명그룹 대표님?!
길에서 주운 노숙자가 알고보니 유명그룹 대표님?!
S시의 최고 재벌 강지혁의 약혼녀가 하루아침에 교통사고로 죽게 되면서 임유진은 음주운전 가해자라는 죄명을 안고 3년 형을 선고받는다. 지옥 같았던 3년간의 복역 생활을 어렵사리 버텨낸 그녀, 겨우 출소하여 자유를 찾는가 싶었는데 소문의 그 강지혁을 건드리게 됐을 줄이야? 남자의 정체를 알게 된 그녀는 그의 앞에 무릎 꿇고 애원했다. “강지혁, 제발 나 좀 놔줘.” 이에 강지혁은 입꼬리를 씩 말아 올렸다. “난 누나 절대 안 놔줘.” 모두 말한다. 강지혁은 피도 눈물도 없는 냉혈한이라고. 하지만 그는 옥살이하고 나온 환경미화원을 위해 간이고 쓸개고 모두 빼줄 것처럼 사랑을 속삭였다. 하지만 교통사고가 나던 날의 진실이 밝혀지면서 둘의 사랑은 산산이 조각나 버린다. 그렇게 두 사람의 사랑은 그녀의 도망으로 그렇게 끝나는 듯했으나……. 몇 년 후의 어느 날, 남자가 그녀의 앞에 무릎 꿇고 애원했다. “유진, 너만 나한테 돌아온다면 나 뭐든 할게.” 그런 남자의 눈빛을 지그시 바라보던 여자의 입에서 이윽고 한마디가 툭 튀어나왔다. “그러면 죽어.”
9.6
1781 Chapters
그리움에 남은 생을 가둘 필요가 있을까
그리움에 남은 생을 가둘 필요가 있을까
“나리야, 너 어릴 때 집안끼리 정혼해 둔 상대가 있단다. 이제 네 건강도 많이 회복됐으니, S 시로 돌아와 결혼하는 게 어떠니?” “네가 정말 원하지 않는다면, 너희 아버지와 다시 상의해서 이 결혼을 없던 일로 해도 괜찮단다.” 어두운 방 안, 송나리는 조용히 앉아 아무 말도 하지 않았다. 전화기 너머에서 어머니 장혜정은 또다시 딸에게 거절당할 것을 예감하며 깊은 한숨을 내쉬려 했다. 그때, 나리가 입을 열었다. “...엄마, 엄마 말씀대로 돌아가서 결혼할게요.” 장혜정은 순간 말을 잃었다. 예상치 못한 딸의 대답이었다. “네가... 정말 동의한다고?” 나리는 평온한 목소리로 대답했다. “네, 동의해요. 하지만 H 시에서 처리해야 할 일이 조금 남아 있어요. 다 정리하고 나서 보름 안에 돌아갈게요. 엄마, 그동안 결혼 준비 부탁드려요.” 그녀는 몇 마디를 더 남긴 후 전화를 끊었다.
29 Chapters
The Shadow Alpha
The Shadow Alpha
His eyes locked with mine and I could feel the strength of the mate bond gnawing at me, but I forced it down. Devin eyed me with annoyance and prominent in his gorgeous grey eyes.“Alpha Devin, this is my daughter.” Papa Jamie said with pride in his voice. Devin gave him a weird look, but turned to me instead. Before he could speak I cut him off with a surveying look from head to toe. He was still as hot as hell if not more; his body was more built and his face more chiseled than before. He looked all man and sue me for finding it sexy. mate bond. My eyes were void of emotion as I looked at the pack that flanked him and back into his stormy grey eyes. I stuck out my hand with a smirk on my face, “Welcome to the Blue Moon Pack.” He grasped my hand and shocks ran up my arm and through my body as it did his causing his eyes to widen, but before he could react I continued. “I am Alpha Allison Trust Wells.” My tone oozed confidence and mirth. I heard a few gasps, but the biggest reaction I got was from Devin whose eyes widened in shock.~~~A story of hurt, betrayal and second chances in a world of mystical creatures. Allison is a young Shewolf with a gift from the Goddess Selene. Join her as she navigates the web of secrets and lies weaved by the people she once thought of as family and learns forgiveness.Not all second chances are started on a clean slate...
9.6
70 Chapters
The Luna and her Quadruplet Pups
The Luna and her Quadruplet Pups
“What’s wrong, Jane, can you not feel me?” Ethan demands, slɑmming his into mine so I feel sure he’ll leave a bruise. “Am I not giving you hard enough?” Still I don’t respond. All I can do is imagine him with Eve, kissing and making lóve to her, giving her all the things he used to give me. I can see their writhing bodies in my mind’s eye, tɑngling the sheets of the Alpha’s bdd. It makes me feel sick to my stomach to know my husband was with the other woman mere hours ago, how does he even have the energy to use me this way when Eve was pleasuring him all night long? *** My husband seeks nothing but to claim me as roughly and thoroughly as he possibly can - and remind me of my proper place. This is what I have to look forward to: a lifetime of pain… unless I finally do what I’ve been planning over the last few months, and ask Ethan for a divorce.I didn’t even know it was possible for an omega to leave an Alpha until recently. Legally, we have almost no rights, but I could request a divorce. Now it is the time. *** Ethan and Jane were childhood sweethearts. However, he is alpha and she is omega. It was almost impossible for them to be fated mate. Ethan did not give up but chose Jane to be his wife and luna. But Fate sure knows how to run with a bit. This young couple messes up their first marriage by lack of trust. Divorce is easy. But what about finding out you were pregnant after divorce?What if you had quadruplets?
9.1
226 Chapters
UNDER THE MOONLIGHT
UNDER THE MOONLIGHT
Part 1 - A GAMMA'S KISS Once a shifter turned 18 they would be able to scent their mates. It felt like this was the moment everyone was waiting for. But not for me. I was happy just to be playing around, one female after another. Why settle for one when you could have a taste of many? But then I tasted her lips. And that one kiss completely changed me. For once, I was ready to give up my old ways just to have a taste of her every day of my life. Part 2 - A BETA'S FATE, AN ALPHA'S DESTINY DOMINIC'S STORY: I kept waiting for my fate to interfere, but at this point, I was already losing hope that I would ever find my mate. Maybe life would be much better with Sofia. I couldn't deny now that I was attracted to her, and maybe that attraction was enough to make me forget Janna. Maybe we could benefit from claiming each other — so she could avoid being claimed by someone she didn't like and me, to not be alone anymore. Because even if I didn't want to admit it, she was slowly creeping her way into my heart. DARVIN'S STORY: My wolf is dying. Soon, I had no choice but to step down as the Alpha of my pack. With the quest to find the perfect Alphas for my sisters, I was already losing time in finding my own mate. But then she appeared out of nowhere, pulling me back into a destiny I was already ready to turn back from.
9.9
97 Chapters
Pleasuring The Maid
Pleasuring The Maid
WARNING!!! This book has mature, threesome content and a MxM relationship with a very unique storyline and emotional rollercoasters. Let us touch you Ava, let us show you how good we can make you feel princess." It was Ray who spoke. His deep yet voice sending shivers down my spine. "Goddess Ava, I want to feel your skin." Bray rasped, already tugging off sweats from my legs. "The Tee goes off too angel." Ray helped me off my Tee, throwing it somewhere on the floor, I couldn't care less. "So full and round, sexy Ava."Ray unclasped my bra, wanting to access my boobs more. ****** Ava is living a life that is all a lie with no idea whatsoever. She ends up wanting two brothers who also realise that their life isn't all they've known. A lie.
8.8
41 Chapters

Related Questions

What Role Did Germs Play In 'Guns, Germs, And Steel'?

4 answers2025-06-20 07:46:21
In 'Guns, Germs, and Steel', germs aren't just background players—they're silent conquerors. Jared Diamond argues that Eurasian societies thrived partly because domesticated animals gave them deadly diseases like smallpox and measles. Over generations, survivors built immunity, but when Europeans collided with the Americas, these germs became weapons. Indigenous populations, never exposed, were decimated, losing up to 90% of their people. This biological asymmetry shaped colonization more than swords or guns. The book flips the script on history. It wasn't European ingenuity alone that dominated—it was their livestock's microbes. Diamond shows how geography blessed Eurasia with animals ideal for domestication, which inadvertently bred lethal pathogens. Meanwhile, isolated continents like Australia lacked this 'germ reservoir,' leaving their populations vulnerable. The chapter on germs reveals a brutal truth: sometimes, evolution writes history.

What Criticisms Exist For 'Guns, Germs, And Steel'?

4 answers2025-06-20 14:29:42
Jared Diamond's 'Guns, Germs, and Steel' is ambitious but faces heavy criticism. Scholars argue it oversimplifies complex historical processes by attributing Eurasian dominance to geography alone. The book ignores cultural, political, and individual agency—factors just as pivotal as environmental luck. Its deterministic lens flattens diverse societies into passive recipients of fate, neglecting innovations like China’s naval tech or the Islamic Golden Age’s scientific leaps. Another gripe is its treatment of indigenous peoples. Critics say Diamond portrays them as inherently disadvantaged rather than resilient adapters to their environments. The ‘continental axis’ theory also stumbles—North America’s north-south orientation didn’t prevent the Maya or Mississippian cultures from flourishing. While gripping, the book feels like a grand narrative straining to fit messy realities into a tidy framework.

How Does 'Guns, Germs, And Steel' View European Colonization?

4 answers2025-06-20 22:10:45
In 'Guns, Germs, and Steel', Jared Diamond argues European colonization wasn't about innate superiority but geographic and environmental luck. Eurasia's east-west axis allowed crops and animals to spread easily, leading to early agriculture and dense populations. That surplus let some societies develop technology, governments, and armies. When Europeans met other cultures, they brought guns, steel weapons, and diseases others had no resistance to—advantages built over millennia, not earned in the moment. The book flips the script: conquest wasn’t destiny but an accident of where people happened to be born. Diamond digs deeper, showing how domesticated animals in Eurasia provided labor, food, and eventually germs that decimated indigenous groups. Europe’s fragmented politics also fostered competition, driving innovation in shipbuilding and warfare. Meanwhile, isolated regions like the Americas or Australia lacked these advantages, making them vulnerable. It’s a humbling take—colonization wasn’t a triumph of will but a twist of fate, with devastating consequences for those on the losing side.

Is 'Guns, Germs, And Steel' Still Relevant Today?

4 answers2025-06-20 00:26:34
Reading 'Guns, Germs, and Steel' feels like uncovering the roots of modern inequality. Jared Diamond's thesis—that geography and environment shaped civilizations—remains a compelling lens. It explains why Europe dominated, not due to innate superiority but because of fertile crops, domesticable animals, and navigable coasts. Today, debates about colonialism and global disparities still echo his arguments. Critics argue it oversimplifies cultural agency, but its core idea holds weight. The book’s relevance lingers in discussions about resource distribution, climate change’s uneven impact, and how historical accidents still dictate fortunes. What’s fascinating is how Diamond’s framework applies to modern tech disparities. Silicon Valley didn’t rise in a vacuum; its success mirrors fertile river valleys of ancient Mesopotamia. Yet, the book’s blind spots—like downplaying human innovation—spark lively critiques. It’s not gospel, but a provocative starting point for understanding why our world looks the way it does.

Does 'Guns, Germs, And Steel' Argue Geography Determines History?

4 answers2025-06-20 18:35:37
Jared Diamond's 'Guns, Germs, and Steel' presents geography as the backbone of historical development, not just a backdrop. He argues that continents like Eurasia thrived because their east-west axis allowed crops, animals, and technologies to spread easily across similar climates. Dense populations and domesticated animals led to advanced societies, while isolated regions like the Americas or Australia faced disadvantages. Geographic luck—fertile land, navigable rivers—gave some groups a head start in farming, which snowballed into political and military dominance. Diamond doesn’t claim geography is destiny, but shows how it stacked the deck. Tropical diseases hindered Africa, while Europe’s fragmented terrain encouraged competition and innovation. His thesis challenges Eurocentric views by highlighting environmental luck over innate superiority. Yet critics say he underestimates culture and human agency. Still, the book’s strength lies in weaving climate, biology, and terrain into a compelling framework for why some societies conquered others.

Why The Nations Fail Vs Guns Germs And Steel Comparison?

4 answers2025-05-22 23:47:00
As someone who loves diving deep into books that explore the grand narratives of human history, I find the comparison between 'Why Nations Fail' and 'Guns, Germs, and Steel' fascinating. 'Why Nations Fail' by Daron Acemoglu and James Robinson argues that institutions—specifically inclusive political and economic systems—are the key to prosperity. They emphasize how extractive institutions lead to failure, using examples like North Korea vs. South Korea. It’s a compelling, politically charged take that feels urgent and relevant today. On the other hand, Jared Diamond’s 'Guns, Germs, and Steel' takes a more geographical and environmental approach. Diamond argues that factors like geography, climate, and available flora/fauna shaped the destinies of civilizations. It’s a sweeping, big-picture view that feels almost deterministic compared to Acemoglu and Robinson’s focus on human agency. While Diamond’s work is brilliant in explaining why Eurasia dominated, it sometimes feels like it downplays the role of culture and choices. Both books are must-reads but offer wildly different lenses on why some nations thrive while others don’t. One feels like a manifesto for change, the other like a grand historical puzzle.

How Does 'Sapiens' Explain The Rise Of Human Societies?

4 answers2025-04-09 08:19:45
'Sapiens' by Yuval Noah Harari dives deep into the evolution of human societies, starting with the Cognitive Revolution around 70,000 years ago. This period marked the emergence of complex language, allowing humans to share ideas, cooperate, and create shared myths. These myths, whether religious, cultural, or political, became the glue that bound large groups together. Next, the Agricultural Revolution around 10,000 years ago transformed nomadic hunter-gatherers into settled farmers. This shift led to population growth and the rise of permanent settlements, but also introduced social hierarchies and inequality. Harari argues that while agriculture provided stability, it wasn’t necessarily a step forward in terms of individual well-being. The book also explores the role of empires and religions in unifying diverse groups under shared systems of belief and governance. Harari emphasizes how money, religion, and empires acted as 'imagined orders,' enabling humans to cooperate on an unprecedented scale. Finally, the Scientific Revolution brought about a new era of exploration, innovation, and industrial growth, shaping the modern world as we know it. Harari’s narrative is both thought-provoking and accessible, offering a fresh lens on human history.

What Do The Various Societies Reveal About Human Nature In 'Gulliver’S Travels'?

4 answers2025-03-27 15:54:50
In 'Gulliver’s Travels', the different societies Gulliver encounters really mirror the best and worst of human nature. For instance, in Lilliput, you see how petty politics and ambition can lead to ridiculous conflicts, reflecting our tendency to get consumed by trivial things. Then there's Brobdingnag, where the giant’s perspective shows how moral superiority can exist without the flaws of greed and cruelty, a kind of idealization of humanity. It’s almost like Swift holds a mirror up to us, exposing our flaws through satire. The Yahoos represent the basest parts of humanity, driven by instinct and chaos, while the Houyhnhnms embody rationality and order, suggesting that perhaps we aren’t as civilized as we think. There’s a deep poignancy in realizing how quickly we can shift between these extremes. If you dig these themes, then 'The Dispossessed' by Ursula K. Le Guin tackles differing societies and philosophies in an engaging way.
좋은 소설을 무료로 찾아 읽어보세요
GoodNovel 앱에서 수많은 인기 소설을 무료로 즐기세요! 마음에 드는 책을 다운로드하고, 언제 어디서나 편하게 읽을 수 있습니다
앱에서 책을 무료로 읽어보세요
앱에서 읽으려면 QR 코드를 스캔하세요.
DMCA.com Protection Status