Is Killing Commendatore A Good Entry To Murakami'S Works?

2025-10-17 15:43:55 175

3 Jawaban

Valeria
Valeria
2025-10-19 13:10:56
Walking into 'Killing Commendatore' felt like opening a door in a house I half-remembered from a dream — familiar Murakami furniture, but rearranged. The novel is long, wildly associative, and patient with its own mysteries, so if you enjoy slow-burn storytelling and surreal detours, it’s a great way to meet his world. The book leans heavily on themes Murakami often revisits: loneliness, the way art becomes a portal, and strange, almost mythic interruptions in everyday life. The opening about the painter and the attic painting sets a tone that lets you settle into oddness rather than expect a tidy plot.

If you’re brand new to him, I’d still recommend coming prepared: relax into the pacing and don't hunt for instant answers. You might prefer starting with something shorter like 'Norwegian Wood' to get a sense of his emotional directness, or 'Kafka on the Shore' if you want surrealism without the epic length. But if you love long, contemplative books that reward patience with moments of eeriness and beauty, 'Killing Commendatore' can be a thrilling first full dive. I personally enjoyed how the novel lets ordinary life and the uncanny coexist, and the painting motif stuck with me for days after I finished it.
Alice
Alice
2025-10-20 06:12:13
If you prefer a brisk verdict wrapped in my usual chatty tone: yes, but with caveats. 'Killing Commendatore' is a doorway to Murakami’s mind more than a neatly plotted gateway drug. It’s full of digressions about music, painting, and the strangeness of human loneliness, and sometimes the plot feels like a pretext for atmosphere. That can be intoxicating or frustrating depending on patience level. I’d tell a friend who likes immersive, slightly eerie long books to jump in; for someone who wants tighter pacing, I’d suggest trying 'Norwegian Wood' first to see if Murakami’s voice clicks.

Either way, reading it feels like having a long, meandering conversation with a witty, melancholic artist; you’ll come away with images and questions rather than simple closure, and I find that lingering uncertainty oddly satisfying.
Xander
Xander
2025-10-23 15:26:10
A quieter take: 'Killing Commendatore' is certainly a valid entry point, though it requires a particular reader temperament. The way Murakami layers anecdotes, metaphysical conceits, and reflective passages means the book reads more like wandering through rooms of thought than sprinting through a plot. If you like novels that allow digressions and enjoy philosophical rumination sprinkled with occasional surreal episodes, this one will welcome you slowly.

Translations matter here; the English version keeps the voice accessible, but the cadence is different from his shorter works. I found myself appreciating the novel more when I treated it as a meditation on creativity and isolation rather than a mystery to be solved. For contrast, readers who want a tighter narrative might try '1Q84' or 'Hard-Boiled Wonderland and the End of the World' after this, because those show different structural experiments. For me, 'Killing Commendatore' worked best when read in stretches, with breaks to mull over the oddities.
Lihat Semua Jawaban
Pindai kode untuk mengunduh Aplikasi

Buku Terkait

Killing booth
Killing booth
Have you ever imagined trying to please everyone but no matter how hard you try, it doesn't change a thing? Well, there is a dark side to every story, don't get so pitiful about mine, I've decided to have a game plan. "Who are you truly?" he asked with fear in his eyes. My boyfriend looked so worried as he stared deeply into my eyes. How am I supposed to find the right words to explain truthfully the truth behind my identity? "You have to leave!" I screamed leaving him in total disappointment.
10
12 Bab
Your love is killing me
Your love is killing me
Not everyone dream of falling hopelessly in love with a bad boy, yet we all face an inescapable destiny. Jane Smith was no exception… Meeting James Watson was both the happiness moment of her life and the path leading to hell. With him surrounded by countless women, she could no longer bear the pain of constant betrayal and deceit. So with a heavy heart she was forced to bring their relationship to a bitter end… hoping to move on peacefully… but her reality would later become a living nightmare. Two years after parting ways, he suddenly returned to state his claim… this time reluctant to let her go. He could care less whether or not she would agree to be his. "You either move into my place or I’ll move into yours… it’s up to you?" He declared arrogantly. When they saw each other again, this was the first thing he said to her.
10
71 Bab
That’s Not How Love Works
That’s Not How Love Works
I fell for my next-door neighbor, James Grayson. I even tried to seduce him in a sexy nightdress. But he humiliated me by throwing me out in front of everyone. I was utterly embarrassed. The next day, he told me straight up that he was getting engaged, and I should just give up. So, I did. I let him go and said yes to someone else’s proposal. But on my wedding day, James showed up looking like a mess and tried to stop the wedding. “Summer, I regret everything.” But by then, my heart already belonged to my husband.
8 Bab
Killing Me Softly
Killing Me Softly
Peace. Home. That's how Dyhein describes her. Devonce Devera. He sees Devi as an angel with black wings, he feels like she is the "Protector of mankind" but he is the one who will turns her into ashes.
Belum ada penilaian
6 Bab
Killing Game Quarter
Killing Game Quarter
11 Students wake up in a completely isolated building, with no way out, and no way to tell the time of day. They are forced to follow the rules of a "Killing Game' in order to earn their freedom, where murdering means a potential escape. From personal tensions and handpicked motivations, will they be able to find a way out before they all drop dead?
10
88 Bab
Killing Nolan Softly
Killing Nolan Softly
"There's only one thing that can make a simple art exhibition so tiring; Evelyn Bennett." *** Nolan is the first son of the Walter Family and the I-Don't-Give-A-Damn kind of playboy. With Mr. Walter getting sick of the position, Noah has to step in as the President of Walter Corporation. Fire meets Fire when Nolan meets Evelyn Bennett, the Lotte Corp Heiress and "competitive-ass". Always getting at each others throats, they would do anything to save their pride and come out triumphant, but when this "hatred" spins into sparks of passion, things can get very crazy and there are obstacles around the corner.
10
17 Bab

Pertanyaan Terkait

What Is The Symbolism Of The Portrait In Killing Commendatore?

4 Jawaban2025-10-17 11:37:24
The portrait in 'Killing Commendatore' reads to me like a loaded time capsule — it’s both mirror and trap. On the surface it’s a painted face, a commissioned likeness, a thing of craft; beneath that surface it holds history, urges, and a trouble that won’t stay silent. The way the painting functions in the story always felt less like an object and more like an active presence: it preserves a moment while also accusing the present, pointing at secrets the characters would rather ignore. I find the most compelling layer is how the portrait blurs responsibility between creator, subject, and viewer. It asks who owns an image once it exists: the painter who put paint to canvas, the sitter who allowed themselves to be fixed, or the people who look and read into it later? In 'Killing Commendatore' this becomes moral and metaphysical — the portrait becomes a repository for historical violence and private loneliness, a vessel for the past that insists on being reckoned with. It’s also a hinge between the ordinary world and the uncanny: once the image is recognized, something else is unlocked, like a door slowly opening to the underground of memory and myth. I keep coming back to the portrait as a symbol of art’s double edge. It preserves and betrays; it humanizes and objectifies. The book made me rethink what it means to make someone “eternal” on a canvas — that act can free a person from oblivion, but it can also chain them to the moment they were painted. That tension stuck with me long after I closed the book.

What Does Killing Commendatore Reveal About Memory?

5 Jawaban2025-10-17 21:13:50
Reading 'Killing Commendatore' taught me to treat memory like an old attic full of paintings and trunks—some labeled, some leaking dust. In the book, memories aren't just recollections; they're almost physical objects that the narrator excavates, paints, and sometimes accidentally wakes up. When the painted Commendatore appears, it feels less like a ghost and more like an artifact of memory that has gained its own agency. I find myself thinking about how memories mutate when you try to preserve them. The novel shows that trying to pin a memory down—by painting it, describing it, or naming it—can both clarify and alter it. The act of remembering becomes an act of creation, and forgetting becomes a decision. That duality stuck with me long after I closed the book; I started noticing how my own attempts to record birthdays, conversations, and small griefs actually reshaped how I felt about them. It's strangely comforting and unsettling at the same time.

Are There Any Film Adaptations Of Killing Commendatore Planned?

4 Jawaban2025-10-17 00:46:40
I'm still buzzing whenever I think about how cinematic 'Killing Commendatore' could be, but to be practical: there hasn't been an official, widely announced film adaptation of 'Killing Commendatore' that I can point to as a done deal. I follow Murakami news pretty closely — between festival chatter, literary translations, and adaptation rumors, big projects get leaked early — and while people float hopeful director names and streaming-service wishlists, nothing concrete has been confirmed publically. There have been successful Murakami adaptations before, like the film version of 'Norwegian Wood' and the brilliant festival run of 'Drive My Car', which proves his work can translate to the screen, but 'Killing Commendatore' poses its own set of headaches for filmmakers. The novel’s length, its surreal metaphysical detours, and its reliance on interior monologue and symbolic imagery all make it harder to compress into a single two-hour movie. I often think a limited series would be a smarter route — streaming platforms love long-form literary adaptations now, and the slow-burn, mysterious atmosphere of the book would breathe in episodic form. There’s also the thorny issue of authorial permission and rights; Murakami’s team tends to be cautious, and adaptations require trust that the director will honor the book’s tone rather than just mining it for spectacle. Personally, I’d be thrilled to see a director who understands mood and subtlety — someone who can translate silence and symbolic imagery as effectively as dialogue. Even if nothing is officially planned yet, every Murakami fan I know keeps a hopeful eye on festival lineups and adaptation announcements. I’d be first in line for tickets or a binge watch if it ever happens.

Which Real-Life Events Inspired Murakami'S Killing Commendatore?

4 Jawaban2025-08-31 10:07:54
I'm the kind of reader who likes to trace a book's shadows back to their real-world shapes, and with 'Killing Commendatore' the trail is delightfully tangled. The clearest single strand is music and myth: Murakami himself and many critics point to Mozart's 'Don Giovanni' — the Commendatore statue that drags the libertine to his doom is literally echoed in the book's title and in the idea of a figure that refuses to stay put. That operatic reference gives the novel a theatrical, moral undertone that feels like an old story retold in modern clothes. Beyond that, the novel feels stitched from contemporary anxieties. Readers and reviewers often link its mood of rupture and uncanny absence to the 2011 Tōhoku earthquake and tsunami, and the long aftershocks of social and environmental disruption. Murakami has long written about Japan's recent traumas in essays and fiction, so it's reasonable to see those real-life tremors — literal and cultural — beneath the fantastical elements of the book. Add to this Murakami's fascination with art, reclusive artists, and hidden paintings (a recurring motif in his interviews about the novel), and you get a work inspired by myths, music, modern disasters, and the small, strange realities of everyday life.

How Does 'Killing And Protecting' End?

5 Jawaban2025-06-12 03:01:00
The ending of 'Killing and Protecting' is a rollercoaster of emotions and twists. The protagonist finally confronts the main antagonist in a climactic battle that’s both physical and psychological. After years of hunting and being hunted, the truth about their shared past unravels—turns out, they were once allies turned enemies due to a tragic misunderstanding. The fight ends with the antagonist sacrificing themselves to save the protagonist, revealing their lingering loyalty. In the aftermath, the protagonist chooses to retire from their violent life, but not before ensuring the safety of those they’ve protected. The final scenes show them walking away into the sunset, leaving their weapons behind, symbolizing a hard-earned peace. The story closes with a hint that their legacy will inspire others, though whether that’s for better or worse is left ambiguous. The blend of redemption, sacrifice, and open-ended future makes the ending resonate deeply.

Who Is The Villain In 'Killing And Protecting'?

5 Jawaban2025-06-12 23:04:39
The villain in 'Killing and Protecting' is a masterfully crafted antagonist named Viktor Hargrove, a ruthless crime lord who operates behind the facade of a legitimate businessman. His influence stretches across the city, controlling everything from drug trafficking to political manipulation. Viktor isn’t just physically intimidating—he’s a psychological predator, exploiting weaknesses in others to maintain his grip. What makes him terrifying is his unpredictability. One moment he’s charming, the next he’s ordering executions without hesitation. His backstory reveals a childhood steeped in violence, shaping him into a cold, calculating monster. The protagonist’s struggle against him isn’t just about physical survival; it’s a battle of wits where one misstep means death. Viktor’s presence looms over every chapter, making him a villain you love to hate.

Where To Read Killing Stalking

5 Jawaban2025-08-01 07:31:42
As someone who's deeply immersed in the world of dark psychological thrillers, I can confidently say that 'Killing Stalking' is a gripping and intense manhwa that's not for the faint of heart. If you're looking to dive into this twisted tale, I highly recommend checking out platforms like Lezhin Comics, Webtoon, or Tappytoon, where you can read it legally and support the creators. Lezhin Comics is my go-to because it offers high-quality translations and frequent updates, though some chapters might require coins. Webtoon is another solid option, especially if you prefer a more streamlined reading experience. Just be prepared for some seriously dark themes—this isn't your typical romance or action story. The tension between Yoon Bum and Sangwoo is unsettling yet fascinating, making it a standout in the psychological horror genre.

Who Is The Antagonist In 'Killing Sarai'?

3 Jawaban2025-06-27 17:14:02
The antagonist in 'Killing Sarai' is Victor Faust, a cold-blooded assassin with a reputation so terrifying even other killers avoid crossing him. What makes him truly dangerous isn’t just his skill with weapons—it’s his mind. He calculates every move like a chessmaster, leaving no room for error. His obsession with Sarai turns from professional to personal, making him unpredictable. Unlike typical villains who rely on brute force, Victor’s power lies in his network. He controls cartels, corrupt officials, and even other assassins, making him untouchable. The way he manipulates Sarai’s past to break her psychologically shows how twisted he is. For readers who enjoy complex villains, Victor stands out because he’s not just evil—he’s methodical about it. If you liked this character, check out 'The Professional' by Kresley Cole for another assassin-driven plot.
Jelajahi dan baca novel bagus secara gratis
Akses gratis ke berbagai novel bagus di aplikasi GoodNovel. Unduh buku yang kamu suka dan baca di mana saja & kapan saja.
Baca buku gratis di Aplikasi
Pindai kode untuk membaca di Aplikasi
DMCA.com Protection Status