but honestly, I bounced off the first one, 'Secret at Skull House.' The plot centers on Emily, a librarian who moves to this small coastal town and inevitably stumbles into solving local murders. The hook is that she's got this secret past tied to the town, which I guess unfolds over the books.
It felt very by-the-numbers to me—quaint setting, a potential love interest in the local detective who tells her to stay out of it, the whole amateur sleuth thing. Maybe I'm just burnt out on the genre, but the pacing was slow, and the 'big secret' from her childhood didn't feel urgent enough to keep me hooked. I hear later books delve more into a cold case involving her mother, which sounds more interesting, but the initial setup didn't grab me.
Some people adore the comfort-food aspect of it, and the bookish angle is always a plus. For me, it was a bit too gentle. I kept waiting for a sharper edge or a weirder clue to pull me in, and it never quite arrived. Your mileage may definitely vary if you're looking for something unchallenging and atmospheric.