Finding common ground in Oli White fanfic is tricky because the source material, his YouTube videos and vlogs, feels so personal and mundane. That normalcy pushes writers towards hyper-specific domestic themes. The biggest thing I see is gentle roommate-to-lovers with Joe Sugg. It's all about quiet mornings in the Brighton apartment, sharing a blanket while binging Netflix, and that unspoken tension during grocery shopping. They build a whole universe out of making tea and teasing about who left the dishes.
Another huge thread is anxiety and comfort. Stories will often explore a version of Oli overwhelmed by the 'algorithm' or a creative block, and another character, often Joe again or sometimes another creator like Caspar Lee, providing grounded reassurance. It's less about dramatic angst and more about portraying that safe-space feeling his fans imagine his real friend group provides. The drama is internal, not external.
A rarer but fascinating angle is introspective, almost meta-fic, where Oli grapples with the performance of his own life. I've seen a few pieces where he wonders if the 'Oli White' on screen is the real him, and a friend helps him separate the two. It's niche, but it shows how his content makes some fans think about authenticity. Most stories, though, are just cozy slices of life—the appeal is the familiarity.