Does 'A Stark New Robb SI' Follow Book Or Show Canon?

As someone who's read both the books and watched 'Game of Thrones', I can tell you 'A Stark New Robb SI' plays fast and loose with canon in the best way. The fic blends elements from George R.R. Martin's 'A Song of Ice and Fire' novels and the HBO adaptation, but leans heavier on book lore. You'll spot deep-cut references like Robb's warging abilities that the show ignored, plus nuanced political dynamics from the books. The author clearly studied the source material - Northern mountain clans get more screen time, and minor characters like Dacey Mormont appear with book-accurate personalities. The SI's knowledge seems drawn from both versions though, mixing show visuals with book plotlines creatively.

Diving into this fanfiction was like uncovering a treasure trove of alternate universe possibilities. The story follows an intriguing middle path between book and show canon, making smart choices about when to deviate from both. Early chapters stick closer to 'A Storm of Swords' events, including the proper chain of command at the Whispering Wood battle that the show simplified. Later arcs incorporate show-only elements like Talisa Maegyr's character, but reinvent her backstory to fit book lore better.

What fascinates me is how the SI's presence creates ripple effects that make both canons irrelevant. The Red Wedding gets completely derailed by Robb making strategic decisions neither book nor show version considered. The fic introduces original twists like Robb negotiating with the Iron Bank early, something neither medium explored. The author's clearly done their homework - they use book-accurate geography for troop movements but keep the show's pacing during battles. It's a masterclass in blended canon storytelling.

Having analyzed dozens of ASOIAF fics, this one stands out for its canon agility. The SI's knowledge base appears primarily show-driven initially - he recalls visual details like the Hound's burnt face clearly. But his actions unlock book-exclusive content immediately, preventing Theon's betrayal through tactics only a book reader would know. The fic treats canon like a buffet, picking the juiciest elements from both versions.

Northern politics follow book rules meticulously - Glover and Mormont banners appear correctly at war councils. Yet the dialogue crackles with the show's modernized wit during small council scenes. The author even fixes continuity errors between mediums - Robb's marriage pact with the Freys gets the proper book terms rather than the show's vague promises. When the story needs tension, it'll suddenly diverge from both canons spectacularly, like having Stannis arrive at Winterfell before the Boltons. This isn't just following canon - it's improving upon it.