Why Do Some Directors Cite The Medium Is Not The Message?

2025-08-27 04:53:45 94

4 คำตอบ

Wesley
Wesley
2025-08-29 00:31:54
I often take a contrarian view at screenings: the argument that 'the medium is not the message' is really a protest against technological or market determinism. Directors know their craft involves choices — framing, pacing, performance, sound design — and they can’t be reduced to the platform their work appears on. When a show moves from cinema to streaming, or a novel becomes a film, what changes are constraints and affordances: runtime limits, budget, censorship, audience expectation. But those are tools, not the theme itself.

Historically, filmmakers have reclaimed authorship through style — the so-called auteurism — precisely to show message stems from intention, not purely medium. I see this in adaptations: 'Memento' uses structure to echo memory, but the core idea remains an exploration of identity, not a manifesto about filmic devices. Directors push back because a wholesale devotion to medium-first thinking removes responsibility for what they actually want to say.
Oliver
Oliver
2025-08-30 09:45:12
I get excited talking about how platforms nudge creators, so when I hear someone claim the medium isn't the message I think of the attention economy. Lately I've noticed short-form apps and algorithm-driven platforms changing how stories get told — 60-second beats, punchy hooks — and many directors push back because they don't want themes squashed into platform-friendly templates. That doesn't mean the medium has no influence; it absolutely does. The camera can lie with angles, editing can reorder truth, and a live theatre's immediacy changes how an audience feels tension.

But from my perspective, saying the medium isn't the message is a defensive, creative stance: it's asserting that ideas, ethics, and character arcs refuse to be fully determined by format. Look at adaptations like 'The Last of Us' — it benefits from television's scope, but the themes of love and survival were already present in the game. Conversely, seeing a play or novel adapted into a film can reveal hidden layers or blunt some edges; that interplay is fascinating. In short, medium matters, but directors remind us meaning emerges from choices, context, and how audiences bring their own baggage to the work.
Reid
Reid
2025-08-30 13:13:52
Sometimes I get into these late-night arguments with friends over whether form dictates meaning, and that's where the phrase 'the medium is not the message' pops up for me. I like to flip McLuhan on its head: sure, the medium shapes possibilities — a close-up in film is a different kind of intimacy than a stage monologue — but directors who say the medium isn't the message are defending the idea that intention, performance, and context carry the real weight.

I had one of those tiny epiphanies watching 'Blade Runner' after reading 'Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?' The cinematic noir mood, the soundtrack, and the rain-drenched visuals gave the film a life separate from the book's themes. The medium added flavor, but the message about memory and humanity lived in the choices: which scenes were kept, which emotions were emphasized. Directors who push back against medium-determinism want to remind us the story, the actors, and the political or personal lens matter more than saying the medium alone defines the meaning. It’s like arguing a guitar makes the song — it helps, but the melody still comes from the person playing it.
Quentin
Quentin
2025-08-30 20:13:02
I like to think of media as different instruments in an orchestra. When a director says 'the medium is not the message', I hear them saying the instrument shouldn't steal the melody. The camera, stage, or console gives unique colors and dynamics, but they’re still serving the story and the intentions behind it.

Practical stuff matters too: studio notes, runtime, and distribution often bend how a story is told, so directors push back to protect themes and tone. A movie can make a joke land differently than a comic, but the point — what you’re trying to say about people or society — can survive the shift if handled deliberately. I usually side with creators who treat medium as a collaborator, not the boss.
ดูคำตอบทั้งหมด
สแกนรหัสเพื่อดาวน์โหลดแอป

หนังสือที่เกี่ยวข้อง

Why Do You Love Me?
Why Do You Love Me?
Two people from two different backgrounds. Does anyone believe that a man who has both money and power like him at the first meeting fell madly in love with her? She is a realist, when she learns that this attractive man has a crush on her, she instinctively doesn't believe it, not only that, and then tries to stay away because she thinks he's just a guy with a lot of money. Just enjoy new things. She must be the exception. So, the two of them got involved a few times. Then, together, overcome our prejudices toward the other side and move towards a long-lasting relationship.
คะแนนไม่เพียงพอ
6 บท
The BTGs: The Spiritual Psychic Medium
The BTGs: The Spiritual Psychic Medium
Isabella Dean was uprooted from her life north of Atlanta at the beginning of her senior year of high school after a tragic accident that killed her father. Her mother took her to live with her aunt, Linda, in Asheville, NC where she was welcomed immediately by the school bully. This encounter got Isabella immediately recognized by a group of girls who befriended her and took her in as one of their friends. As she adjusted to her new life, she continued to have to protect herself from the bully, Lucy Upshaw, and recover from a hidden brain injury sustained in the accident. While in the hospital, she died and returned changed and with gifts she had to learn to live with. She discovered along with her new friend, Amber Collins, that her house was haunted by a mysterious girl. She and Amber also rescued a group of girls from sex traffickers and helped the victims flee. She and her friends helped get them adopted by local families, but they also had to deal with the bigotry of some people who didn’t like that some of the girls were transgender and genetically modified by their assailants. Isabella, meanwhile, had to deal with her own problems with her mother and recover from her surgery while still being attacked by Lucy. This is just the beginning for these girls who learn how to fight ghosts and demons with the help of their Native American friend, Winona. They learn to use their talents to help others deal with things that go bump in night.
คะแนนไม่เพียงพอ
12 บท
 Do You Or Do You Not Want Me, Mate?
Do You Or Do You Not Want Me, Mate?
When Travis, Serena's mate, picked her sister over her, she couldn't help but think her fear had come true. She was denied by her mate. Choosing the easy way out of the heartbreak, she ran away with no intention of going back. But, it wasn't that easy when her older brother managed to track her down and demanded for her to come home. And when she does, secrets will pop out and she will find herself in a situation that she never thought would end up in.
คะแนนไม่เพียงพอ
9 บท
Some Other Lifetimes
Some Other Lifetimes
The story is a mixture of fantasy, a bit of comedy, unconventional romance, and addressing issues that people encounter everyday rolled into one. This ought to leave meaningful lessons about love, one's existence, new beginnings , and dealing with the different nuances of life.
คะแนนไม่เพียงพอ
30 บท
Why Mr CEO, Why Me
Why Mr CEO, Why Me
She came to Australia from India to achieve her dreams, but an innocent visit to the notorious kings street in Sydney changed her life. From an international exchange student/intern (in a small local company) to Madam of Chen's family, one of the most powerful families in the world, her life took a 180-degree turn. She couldn’t believe how her fate got twisted this way with the most dangerous and noble man, who until now was resistant to the women. The key thing was that she was not very keen to the change her life like this. Even when she was rotten spoiled by him, she was still not ready to accept her identity as the wife of this ridiculously man.
9.7
62 บท
The General Craves Some Meat
The General Craves Some Meat
Xue Han, a fierce general who loves his peace more than anything, hates loud people the most. He is feared throughout the capital for he was appointed General when he was barely eighteen years old. He has never lost a battle since then. One day he falls in love with the Cheng siblings who are very close to each other and love one another the most. Would his love for these two cause trouble for these siblings or will it bring the two closer to one another?
10
13 บท

คำถามที่เกี่ยวข้อง

Where Is The Happy Medium Between Nostalgia And New Plots?

8 คำตอบ2025-10-22 14:24:33
I get a little giddy picturing the perfect blend of old and new—it's like remixing a cherished song so it still makes you cry but also surprises you with a sick new hook. For me the happy medium starts with respect: keep the emotional core and character beats that made the original matter. If 'Final Fantasy VII' taught us anything, it's that folks love Cloud and the themes of identity and loss; reboots or sequels that ignore those foundations feel hollow. That doesn't mean slavish repetition. Bring new themes, fresh conflicts, and modern pacing so a story can breathe for newcomers as well as long-time fans. Practically, I look for works that use nostalgia as seasoning, not the whole meal. Clever callbacks, familiar motifs, and visual nods are great when they reward attention without gating the plot. A soft reboot or a new POV can help—think of stories that expand the world rather than retell it beat-for-beat. Games like 'Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse' show how you can celebrate legacy while delivering a truly original narrative voice. Also, medium matters: comics can serialize side stories, anime can do filler arcs that explore themes, and games can add new mechanics that reinterpret old beats. Ultimately, balance means caring about character truth and stakes. If a new plot advances what the original cared about—rather than just trading on nostalgia for clicks—fans usually forgive surprises. I love being surprised in my favorite universes, so when creators honor the heart and bring something genuinely new, I get that warm, giddy feeling that keeps me coming back.

What Is The Main Message Of Amanda Kloots' Book?

4 คำตอบ2025-10-23 17:49:01
In 'Live Your Life,' Amanda Kloots shares a deeply personal narrative that pulsates with resilience and hope. The book beautifully encapsulates her journey through profound loss and the strength she's discovered while navigating life's challenges. At its core, the main message shines through: live fully and authentically, embracing each moment as it comes. Kloots' storytelling is both inspiring and raw, as she delves into her experiences with grief after the heartbreaking loss of her husband, Nick Cordero. What struck me the most is her emphasis on the value of cherishing relationships and taking chances, which resonates with anyone facing uncertainty. The encouragement to turn pain into purpose really changed how I look at my own obstacles, pushing me to seek joy and connection even in tough times. This book is a soothing reminder that amidst darkness, there is light to be found. The way Amanda intertwines personal anecdotes and practical advice makes her message accessible and relatable. It's not just a memoir; it’s a guide for living passionately. In a world often overshadowed by setbacks, Kloots reminds us to embrace our lives, get out of our comfort zones, and let love lead the way. You can feel her heart in every page, making it a must-read for anyone needing encouragement in their journey. This book left me feeling inspired and with a newfound appreciation for the power of resilience. Definitely one I’d recommend to friends!

What Is The Main Message Of The Absolutely True Diary Of A Part-Time Indian?

4 คำตอบ2025-11-10 12:34:03
Man, 'The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian' hit me like a freight train when I first read it. Sherman Alexie’s raw, unfiltered voice through Junior’s perspective is a punch to the gut in the best way possible. The book’s core message? It’s about defiance—defying the suffocating expectations of poverty, race, and circumstance. Junior’s decision to leave the rez school for a white-dominated one isn’t just about education; it’s a rebellion against the idea that he’s destined to fail. But here’s the kicker: it’s also about the cost of that defiance. The guilt, the alienation from his community, even the friction with his best friend Rowdy—it all paints this messy, beautiful picture of what it means to chase hope when everything around you screams 'give up.' And then there’s the humor. God, the humor! Junior’s cartoons and self-deprecating jokes make the heavy themes digestible, but they also underscore resilience. The message isn’t just 'break free,' but 'laugh while you do it, even if it hurts.' The book refuses to romanticize either the rez or the white world, showing both as flawed. It’s a story about straddling two identities and finding your own path—not perfectly, but authentically. That final basketball game with Rowdy? Chills. It’s not a tidy resolution, but it’s real. Alexie leaves you with this lingering thought: hope isn’t a guarantee, but it’s worth fighting for, even when the fight fractures you.

What Is The Main Message Of The Demon-Haunted World: Science As A Candle In The Dark?

3 คำตอบ2025-11-10 04:03:55
You know, 'The Demon-Haunted World' isn't just about debunking aliens or ghosts—it's Carl Sagan's love letter to critical thinking. I read it during a phase where I was obsessed with conspiracy theories, and it flipped my perspective entirely. Sagan doesn't just dismiss weird beliefs; he teaches you how to ask questions like a scientist. The 'baloney detection kit' chapter? Life-changing. It's not about being a skeptic for the sake of it, but about valuing evidence over comfort. That idea stuck with me when I caught myself falling for online hoaxes later. What's wild is how relevant it feels today. The book warns about a society that ignores science, and boy, does that hit differently post-pandemic. Sagan’s candle metaphor isn’t poetic fluff—it’s urgent. When I see people distrusting vaccines or claiming AI art is haunted (yes, really), I think of this book. It’s not preachy; it’s a toolkit for survival in an age of misinformation. My dog-eared copy now lives next to my 'X-Files' DVDs—irony intended.

What Message Do Hero Mariah Carey Lyrics Deliver To Listeners?

3 คำตอบ2025-08-28 05:34:16
When 'Hero' begins with that gentle piano and Mariah's voice slips in, it feels like someone handing you a flashlight in a dark room. I’ve sung it at family gatherings, hummed it on the subway, and watched strangers get misty during the chorus — because the message is simple and stubbornly comforting: the strength you need is already inside you. Lines like 'There's a hero if you look inside your heart' are almost conversational, not preachy, and that makes the song work. It doesn’t promise miracles; it asks you to recognize your own resilience. As someone who grew up on mixtapes and church performances, I find 'Hero' operates on two levels. Musically it builds — quiet verses to anthemic choruses — so the lyrics are reinforced by emotional lift. Lyrically, it acknowledges fear and doubt but reframes them: courage isn't the absence of fear, it’s moving forward despite it. That’s why people use the song at graduations, memorials, and when someone needs encouragement. It’s universal without being generic. I also love that the song invites participation. You can belt it in the car, whisper it at 2 a.m., or pass it on to someone who needs to hear it. It’s a gentle reminder more than a command, and I always come away feeling like I can try again — or tell a friend they can, too.

What Is The Main Message Of 'The Courage To Be Disliked'?

2 คำตอบ2025-10-09 15:42:07
Reflecting on 'The Courage to Be Disliked', I find its core message revolves around the idea of personal freedom and self-acceptance. The dialogue between the philosopher and the young man serves as a thought-provoking exploration of how we often let the opinions of others dictate our self-worth and happiness. One standout theme is the power of choice—how we can choose our responses to circumstances instead of being victims of our past or societal expectations. It's empowering, really. The takeaway that resonates with me the most is the notion that we can live authentically, shedding the weight of seeking validation from others. I also love how the book ties in principles from Adlerian psychology, emphasizing that feelings of inferiority are universal and that everyone struggles with self-doubt. This makes the journey of introspection feel more relatable, right? Rethinking the concept of ‘dislike’ as something that shouldn’t hold us back encourages us to embrace who we are, flaws and all. The characters’ conversations remind me of those late-night chats with friends where we dissect each other’s fears and insecurities, but also laugh about them and ultimately inspire growth. The encouragement to confront uncomfortable truths about ourselves is almost liberating. The idea that happiness lies in the pursuit of community rather than in personal gain adds another layer of depth to the discussion. It proposes that true satisfaction comes from our relationships and contributions to the world around us, which is a balm for those of us who often feel overwhelmed by individual achievement. In reflecting on my own life, I realize how often I’ve let external pressures dictate my path. This book has inspired me to cultivate courage within myself and to celebrate the moments when I choose to follow my own path, regardless of disapproval.

Why Is 'Love Yourself' Important To BTS Message?

5 คำตอบ2025-09-11 19:12:32
When I first dived into BTS's music, what struck me hardest wasn't just their beats or choreography—it was how relentlessly their lyrics champion self-acceptance. Tracks like 'Epiphany' and 'Answer: Love Myself' feel like personal letters urging listeners to embrace their flaws. It's raw, vulnerable stuff that contrasts sharply with K-pop's usual glamour. Their UN speeches expanded this into a global movement, making 'Love Yourself' feel less like a slogan and more like the heartbeat of their art. What's fascinating is how this theme evolved. Early songs like 'No More Dream' tackled societal pressures, but by the 'Love Yourself' trilogy, the focus turned inward. It mirrors their own journey—seven guys who started as underdogs, wrestling with insecurities before learning to own their stories. That authenticity resonates; you don't just hear their message, you watch them live it through scandals, burnout, and military enlistments. Their concerts even incorporate fan projects where ARMYs hold up mirrors during 'Magic Shop,' literally reflecting the message back. It's cheesy in theory, but when thousands do it together? Chills.

In What Ways Do The Relationships Evolve In 'Message In A Bottle'?

3 คำตอบ2025-04-04 18:16:07
In 'Message in a Bottle', the relationships evolve in a deeply emotional and gradual way. Theresa, a journalist, discovers a heartfelt letter in a bottle written by Garrett, a grieving widower. Their connection starts through these letters, which are raw and honest, allowing them to bond on a level that feels almost fated. As they meet in person, their relationship grows from curiosity to a profound emotional attachment. Garrett struggles with his past love, and Theresa navigates her own insecurities, but their shared vulnerability brings them closer. The evolution is marked by moments of hesitation, breakthroughs, and ultimately, a love that feels both fragile and unbreakable. It’s a journey of healing, trust, and rediscovering the courage to love again.
สำรวจและอ่านนวนิยายดีๆ ได้ฟรี
เข้าถึงนวนิยายดีๆ จำนวนมากได้ฟรีบนแอป GoodNovel ดาวน์โหลดหนังสือที่คุณชอบและอ่านได้ทุกที่ทุกเวลา
อ่านหนังสือฟรีบนแอป
สแกนรหัสเพื่ออ่านบนแอป
DMCA.com Protection Status