14 คำตอบ2026-08-04 00:09:45
Does it even matter? The story is so good on its own. Koichi, Pop, and Knuckleduster are compelling enough that you don't need Deku and Bakugo to show up.
But since you asked, the general consensus is that Vigilantes concludes its story shortly before the U.A. entrance exam that kicks off the main series. Vol 8 is in the final stretch of that conclusion. The threats become bigger, the lines between vigilante and hero blur, and you can feel the timeline converging. It’s like watching an origin story for the era itself.
11 คำตอบ2026-08-04 18:22:10
The fan translation scene years ago made timeline talk more chaotic because people read chapters as they were scanlated, out of sync with the main series releases. Now, with official volumes, it's simple: read the 15 volumes in order. Vol 4 is the fourth one. Done.
If you're a timeline completist, read all of 'Vigilantes' after you finish the 'My Hero Academia' manga arc where Sir Nighteye is introduced. That gives you the full context for the hero society and its flaws. But it's not a rule. Vol 4's story is self-contained enough that you only need the prior Vigilantes volumes to understand it. Its emotional core—protecting your friends—is universal and doesn't require a PhD in MHA lore.
10 คำตอบ2026-08-04 14:05:35
Captain Celebrity's whole arc is a wild, satirical connection. This narcissistic, media-obsessed hero from America shows the global hero culture's flaws before we ever see Star and Stripe. His reluctant growth and eventual return to the U.S. sets a precedent for the kind of heroism that exists outside Japan's system. It's a fun, cynical look at heroics as a celebrity industry, which the main series touches on but never explores with such a focused, comedic character.
11 คำตอบ2026-08-04 11:34:28
Honestly, the timeline is a bit fuzzy if you try to map it episode-by-episode. ‘Vigilantes’ runs parallel as a prequel, with volume 2 solidifying the Naruhata setting and its quirky, lower-stakes conflicts. You won’t find Midoriya or Bakugo here; it’s Koichi’s story. The connection is more thematic and world-building than direct plot crossover. I’d treat it as its own thing that occasionally winks at the main series, especially with younger versions of familiar pros. Trying to slot it in too precisely might ruin the fun—just enjoy it as a standalone story that happens to share the same universe.
14 คำตอบ2026-08-04 02:19:17
It's worth noting that Vigilantes explores the concept of 'failed heroes' or those who never made it into the system. Knuckleduster is the prime example—a man with immense skill but no quirk, operating in a world that increasingly values flashy powers. His entire character is a critique of the hero society's nascent elitism, which is still forming in this timeline. In the main series, this critique is embodied by Stain or Lady Nagant, but Vigilantes shows its roots. It's a social commentary that feels more immediate because we're seeing the system being built, not just reacting to its failures decades later.
13 คำตอบ2026-08-04 12:50:26
You could almost split the series into 'Before Forest Training' and 'After Forest Training.' Vol 10 is the 'Before.' It's the final exam of their initial innocence. After this, the villains' war escalates dramatically.
16 คำตอบ2026-08-04 17:13:19
Ultimately, 'where it fits' is in the reader's appreciation. Reading it after the War Arc gives you a profound sense of melancholy. Reading it before gives you a thrilling sense of foreboding. The volume is masterfully written to work either way.
Its placement in the timeline is deliberately fluid, serving as both a prequel and a concurrent narrative. The most important thing is that it's a fantastic read with some of the best action sequences and character payoffs in the entire 'MHA' expanded universe. Don't let timeline anxiety stop you from enjoying it.
9 คำตอบ2026-08-04 07:04:35
The antagonist in this volume is terrifying, but their menace comes from the mystery and buildup in Volumes 7 and 8. Volume 9 is when they finally take center stage in a full confrontation. So, order-wise, it's after the shadowy threat becomes a clear and present danger.
It's the 'reveal and confrontation' volume for that particular villain.
6 คำตอบ2026-08-04 02:34:50
I appreciate that it doesn't force connections. No deus ex machina where Koichi shows up to save Deku. The timelines touch through shared characters and themes, not through plot interference. It respects the integrity of both stories. This makes the world feel vast and real—not every important person in the world knows each other or intersects directly. Sometimes, history is just happening in the same world, separately.
10 คำตอบ2026-08-04 12:52:08
The library binding on my Vol 8 is loose from rereading the All Might fight. That sequence alone makes its timeline placement memorable. It's the culmination of the 'Deku and Bakugo need to work together' thread that started at the very beginning. It's a milestone volume.