Well, this depends so much on the person receiving it. I gifted 'The Complete Poems of Erin Hanson' to my sister last Christmas because she's always posting sunset photos with vague, wistful captions. It seemed like a perfect fit, right? She was polite, but I could tell it wasn't her thing. The poems are very accessible and focus on nature, self-belief, and wonder—which can feel uplifting or, depending on your taste, a bit repetitive and saccharine. The artwork in some editions is pretty, though, and the books are well-made as physical objects.
For a casual poetry reader or someone who enjoys motivational quotes and imagery about mountains and stars, it's a safe, pleasant choice. But if they're into more complex, layered, or challenging poetry, something by Mary Oliver or even contemporary poets like Ocean Vuong might resonate more deeply. I'd say it's a good gift if you know the recipient already likes that style—maybe they follow her on Instagram. Otherwise, it's a bit of a gamble. My copy mostly sits on the coffee table, but it does get flipped through when people are over.