If you’re poking around Goodreads to see how 'One-Punch Man' vol. 1 lands with readers, the short version I’d give is: pleasantly high and enthusiastic, with most people clustering around 4 or 5 stars. I’ve checked the community chatter a few times between subway stops and every few months it tilts the same way — lots of praise for the art, wry comments about the humor, and a handful of nitpicks from people who expected a deeper drama instead of parody.
Most of the longer reviews gush over Yusuke Murata’s artwork and the way the book plays with superhero and shonen tropes. You’ll see folks saying things like, “breathtaking panels” or “I laughed out loud at Saitama’s deadpan,” and those are usually 5-star reactions. The 3-star and 2-star reviews often come from readers who felt the volume was too short, or that the joke wears thin if you wanted a more traditional hero arc. A few 1-star reviews pop up, usually from people who simply didn’t connect to the humor or pacing.
If you want the raw vibe: Goodreads readers generally love this first volume for its freshness and art, but some warn that it’s a setup volume — big laughs and great fights, not a ton of emotional deep-dives yet. I personally keep this on my coffee-table shelf because it’s one of those books that brightens a dull evening.