Rocks Pirates and Roger Pirates are two legendary crews from the golden age of piracy, but comparing their strength isn’t straightforward. The Rocks Pirates, led by Rocks D. Xebec, were a chaotic, unruly force with future powerhouses like Big Mom, Kaido, and Whitebeard under their banner. Their infighting and lack of unity might’ve been their downfall, but individually, their members became some of the strongest pirates in history. On the other hand, the Roger Pirates, under Gol D. Roger, were a tightly-knit crew that conquered the Grand Line and reached Laugh Tale. Their synergy and Roger’s leadership made them unstoppable, even against Rocks during the God Valley incident.
While the Rocks crew had raw power in spades, the Roger Pirates’ cohesion and purpose might’ve given them the edge in an all-out battle. It’s like comparing a storm to a sharpened blade—both terrifying, but in different ways. I lean toward Roger’s crew simply because they achieved what no one else could, but imagining a full-scale war between them is pure hype fuel.