When I first dove back into the world of cats, I learned the hard way that how you read 'Warriors' changes the whole vibe of the story. If you want my enthusiastic vote: start with publication order. That means reading the arcs as they came out — 'The Prophecies Begin', then 'The New Prophecy', 'Power of Three', 'Omen of the Stars', 'Dawn of the Clans', 'A Vision of Shadows', 'The Broken Code', and then the newest arcs. Publication order preserves the pacing, reveals, and emotional beats Erin Hunter built, so plot twists land the way they were meant to. I personally did this with a friend and we kept texting each other after cliffhangers for days — it’s a whole mood.
Super editions, novellas, and field guides are best sprinkled in when they match the timeline or when you want a breather. For example, read character super editions around the arcs where those characters are important, and slot novellas either between arcs or after finishing an arc to avoid spoiling future events. Manga can be a fun side trip: most manga are stand-alone or adapt small parts, so I read them between arcs as palate cleansers. If you like lore, pause for 'Secrets of the Clans' or 'Code of the Clans' — they’re delightful detours that deepen StarClan and Clan history.
If you want a different experience, chronological order gives origin context (especially for 'Dawn of the Clans'), but for a first-time read I swear by publication order. It made my first re-read feel like visiting old friends with better understanding, and it’s how most long-time readers still recommend it.