Did P L Travers Approve The Disney Mary Poppins Movie?

2025-06-02 16:18:37 307

4 answers

Delilah
Delilah
2025-06-06 09:26:16
As someone deeply fascinated by the intersection of literature and film, the dynamic between P.L. Travers and Disney over 'Mary Poppins' is a compelling story. Travers famously clashed with Walt Disney during the production of the 1964 film. While she initially sold the rights hoping for a faithful adaptation, she was deeply unhappy with Disney's musical, whimsical interpretation. Travers disliked the animation sequences, the softened portrayal of Mary Poppins, and the overall sugarcoating of her darker, more nuanced books.

Despite her objections, the film became a cultural phenomenon. Travers' disapproval was so strong that she later stipulated in her will that no Americans could be involved in future adaptations—a clear jab at Disney. Her complex relationship with the film is well-documented in 'Saving Mr. Banks,' which dramatizes her creative battles with Disney. It's a fascinating case of artistic vision clashing with commercial appeal, and Travers' stance remains a testament to her fierce protectiveness of her work.
Wesley
Wesley
2025-06-05 15:06:59
I’ve always been intrigued by the behind-the-scenes drama of classic films, and P.L. Travers' reaction to Disney’s 'Mary Poppins' is legendary. She reluctantly agreed to the adaptation after years of persuasion but was horrified by the final product. Travers hated the cheerful songs, the animated scenes, and how Mary Poppins lost her stern, mysterious edge. She even cried at the premiere, feeling her creation had been turned into something unrecognizable.

Travers’ disdain was so profound that she refused to sell the rights to the sequel books. The film’s success didn’t sway her; she saw it as a betrayal of her original vision. This tension adds a layer of irony to the movie’s legacy—beloved by millions, yet rejected by its own creator. It’s a stark reminder of how adaptations can diverge wildly from their source material.
Caleb
Caleb
2025-06-05 18:16:29
P.L. Travers’ disapproval of Disney’s 'Mary Poppins' is one of those iconic author-versus-Hollywood stories. She sold the rights under pressure but regretted it almost immediately. Travers wanted a darker, more faithful adaptation, but Disney’s version leaned into music and fantasy, which she felt trivialized her work. She fought against changes during production, even arguing with Walt Disney himself, but ultimately lost control of the creative direction.

The film’s cheerful tone clashed with her original vision, and she never reconciled with it. Travers’ frustration is understandable—her books were layered with psychological depth, while the movie prioritized broad appeal. It’s a classic example of creative differences, and her legacy remains tied to both the book’s brilliance and the film’s divergence from it.
Emma
Emma
2025-06-06 09:45:26
P.L. Travers famously did not approve of Disney’s 'Mary Poppins.' She disliked its musical numbers, animation, and the way it softened Mary Poppins’ character. Travers felt the film strayed too far from her books’ sharper tone. Despite its success, she refused to collaborate with Disney again. Her disapproval is a key part of the film’s history, highlighting the tension between literary and cinematic interpretations.
ดูคำตอบทั้งหมด
สแกนรหัสเพื่อดาวน์โหลดแอป

Related Books

อาณาจักรรักอสรพิษ l THE BEAST X SERPENT
อาณาจักรรักอสรพิษ l THE BEAST X SERPENT
"จงสำนึกผิดต่อบาปของเจ้า แม้ต้องแลกด้วยร่างกายและวิญญาณ ก็จงน้อมรับการชำระแค้นจากข้าเสีย" บาบารัส พญางูยักษ์สลักคำสาปด้วยนำเสียงกึกก้องกัมปนาทหมายให้กรีนชดใช้ในสิ่งที่ก่อ
คะแนนไม่เพียงพอ
56 Chapters
เรื่องของเรา3p แพท
เรื่องของเรา3p แพท
สายตาที่เค้ามองมา ทำให้ฉันคล้ายกับว่า กำลังเปลือยเปล่าต่อหน้าเค้า สายตาที่เธอมองผม ทำให้แก่นกลางกายขยับขึ้นอย่างน่าอาย รักที่เร่าร้อน แอบแฝง ปิดบัง 3p. ผมต้องห้ามใจ เพราะเธอมีเจ้าของแล้ว ฉันต้องมองแค่แฟนของฉันคนเดียวเท่านั้น อย่าไปคิดถึงเค้า นิยายของเลขา และ เจ้านาย ที่อยากเป็นมากกว่านั้น คาสโนว่า ตัวพ่อ ที่อยากได้ เลขาของตัวเอง แต่เธอมีคนของเธอ ถ้า คนของเธอ ดูแลไม่ดี เขาจะแย่งเธอมา
10
35 Chapters
ทวงรักนายหัว LoveSick (NC25+)
ทวงรักนายหัว LoveSick (NC25+)
เธอทิ้งเขาไปไม่ไยดี เมื่อได้เจอกันอีกครั้ง เขาจึงตามเอาคืนให้สาสม...“จำเอาไว้! ชีวิตเธอ ร่างกายเธอ ทุกอย่างของเธอเป็นของฉัน ฉันจะปล่อยเธอเป็นอิสระเมื่อไหร่ ก็ขึ้นอยู่กับฉันเท่านั้น!!"
คะแนนไม่เพียงพอ
121 Chapters
ทวงรักท่านประธานมาเฟีย LoveSick (NC25+)
ทวงรักท่านประธานมาเฟีย LoveSick (NC25+)
“เบื่อ! อย่ากลับมาให้ฉันเห็นหน้าอีก” นั่นคือคำที่ ‘เขา’ พูดไว้ ก่อนจะหักอกและทิ้งให้เธอ..เจ็บปวดปางตาย
คะแนนไม่เพียงพอ
100 Chapters
My best friend สุภาพบุรุษสุดที่รัก
My best friend สุภาพบุรุษสุดที่รัก
คนสองคนที่เป็นเพื่อนกันมา20ปี และยังคงสถานะการเป็นเพื่อนไว้ จะทำยังไงกันดีหากอีกคนความรู้สึกเปลี่ยนไป หวานตาเริ่มมีความรัก จนทำให้ตัวเองห่างเหินจากเพื่อน จวบจนวันหนึ่ง ความรักที่ตัวเองทึกทักไปเองจบลง หวานตารู้สึกเคว้งคว้าง เธอหันมาปรึกษาเพื่อนlสนิท ภูมิเป็นที่ปรึกษาที่ดี เขาช่วยให้เธอรู้สึกดีขึ้น แต่แล้ว...ไอ้ความรู้สึกแปลกๆ ที่เกิดขึ้น ตอนที่ภูมิมีผู้หญิงมาสนใจนี่ล่ะ มันคืออะไรอีกหะ? หวานตาไม่ใคร่เข้าใจตัวเองนักหรอก เธอไม่พอใจอะไร? หากเพื่อนของเธอจะทดลองมีความรักบ้าง... แต่มันเป็นเพราะเธอ...รัก เพื่อนที่ยังคงเป็นเพื่อนอยู่นั่นเอง เธอจะจัดการอย่างไรกับความรู้สึกที่เกิดขึ้น ครั้นจะบอกภูมิตรงๆ เธอก็กลัวว่าความเป็นเพื่อนที่มีมายาวนานจะจบลง หากในอนาคต ไม่มีภูมิในชีวิต หวานตาแน่ใจ...เธอคงเฟลไปตลอดชีวิตเหมือนกัน เมื่อเพื่อนเริ่มมีผู้หญิงมาสนใจ หวานตาเริ่มเสียเซลฟ์ เธอไม่ใช่คนสำคัญอันดับหนึ่งของภูมิอีกต่อไปแล้ว เธอเลยรีบมูฟออนออกมาจากจุดที่เคยอยู่ประจำ เธอไม่อยากเป็นแค่เพื่อน...แต่อยากเป็นคนสำคัญของเขา
คะแนนไม่เพียงพอ
77 Chapters
แผนร้ายตีตรารัก
แผนร้ายตีตรารัก
ก่อนโบ้ : ”ป้องกันด้วยฉันไม่ต้องการเด็ก“ l ตอนโบ้ : ”เมียจ๋า...อย่าพาลูกหนีไปจากผัวเลยนะคะ พี่อยู่ไม่ได้ถ้าไม่มีเมียจ๋า“
คะแนนไม่เพียงพอ
31 Chapters

Related Questions

Are There Any P L Travers Novels Adapted Into Anime?

4 answers2025-06-02 08:27:26
As a lifelong fan of both classic literature and anime adaptations, I've dug deep into this topic! P.L. Travers' 'Mary Poppins' series is her most famous work, but surprisingly, there aren't any direct anime adaptations of her novels. However, the 1988 anime film 'Mary and the Witch's Flower' by Studio Ponoc carries strong thematic similarities—whimsical magic, flying umbrellas, and a mysterious female protagonist. It feels like a spiritual cousin to Travers' work. That said, Travers' writing style with its British sensibilities hasn't translated directly into anime, likely due to cultural differences. But elements of her stories pop up in shows like 'Kiki's Delivery Service', where a young witch navigates independence with magical flair. If you love Travers' blend of fantasy and life lessons, these anime capture similar vibes beautifully. Maybe one day we'll get a full 'Mary Poppins' anime!

What Awards Did P L Travers Win For Her Novels?

4 answers2025-06-02 02:15:59
P.L. Travers is a name that resonates deeply in literary circles, especially for her iconic 'Mary Poppins' series. While she didn’t win a ton of major literary awards, her impact was undeniable. The New York Times named 'Mary Poppins' one of the Outstanding Books of the Year in 1934, which was a huge honor at the time. Later, in 1978, she received the prestigious Order of the British Empire (OBE) for her contributions to literature. Though she wasn’t showered with awards like some authors, her work’s cultural significance and timeless appeal have cemented her legacy. The fact that 'Mary Poppins' has been adapted into films, stage plays, and more speaks volumes about its enduring charm. Her storytelling, blending whimsy and wisdom, continues to inspire generations of readers and writers alike.

Where Can I Read P L Travers Books Online For Free?

4 answers2025-06-02 10:16:05
As someone who spends a lot of time exploring digital libraries and book-sharing platforms, I’ve found that accessing P.L. Travers' books for free can be tricky but not impossible. Websites like Project Gutenberg and Open Library often host older works that are in the public domain. While Travers' most famous work, 'Mary Poppins,' might be under copyright, some of her lesser-known writings or essays could be available there. Another option is checking out your local library’s digital services, like OverDrive or Libby. Many libraries offer free e-books, including classics. If you’re into audiobooks, Librivox has volunteer-read public domain books, though Travers’ works might not be fully represented. Just remember to respect copyright laws—some platforms claim to offer free books but aren’t legal, so sticking to reputable sources is key.

Which Publishers Released P L Travers' Original Books?

4 answers2025-06-02 06:58:21
As someone who adores classic children's literature, I've always been fascinated by the origins of 'Mary Poppins' and its creator, P.L. Travers. Her original books were primarily published by two major houses. The first was Harcourt, Brace & Company in the U.S., which released the initial editions of 'Mary Poppins' in 1934. Later, the UK publisher Gerald Howe took on the British editions. Over time, other publishers like Collins and Houghton Mifflin also handled reprints and translations. It's interesting to note how Travers' work evolved across different publishers, each adding their own touch to the iconic nanny's legacy. The U.S. editions often had subtle differences in illustrations and even text compared to the UK versions, making them collectibles for fans like me.

What Inspired P L Travers To Create Mary Poppins?

4 answers2025-06-02 15:58:15
As someone who has always been fascinated by the stories behind beloved characters, I find the inspiration for 'Mary Poppins' particularly intriguing. P.L. Travers drew from her own childhood memories and the eccentric figures in her life to create the magical nanny. Her relationship with her father, who was both charming and unreliable, influenced Mary Poppins' enigmatic personality—strict yet whimsical. Travers also incorporated elements from her love of mythology and fairy tales, blending them with the everyday struggles of a London family. The character’s name supposedly came from a childhood friend, and her adventures reflect Travers' own longing for escapism and wonder. Another layer of inspiration came from Travers' fascination with Eastern spirituality and mysticism. She traveled extensively and studied under gurus, which seeped into Mary Poppins' mystical abilities and her almost otherworldly presence. The Banks family’s dynamics mirror Travers' own complicated feelings about family and responsibility, making the story deeply personal. It’s this mix of reality and fantasy, grounded in Travers' life experiences, that gives 'Mary Poppins' its timeless appeal.

Where Can I Buy Signed P L Travers First Editions?

4 answers2025-06-02 04:59:46
As a collector of rare books, I've spent years hunting for signed first editions, and P.L. Travers' works are some of the most sought-after. Your best bet is to check specialized rare book dealers like AbeBooks, Biblio, or even Heritage Auctions, where signed 'Mary Poppins' editions occasionally surface. I once snagged a copy from a small bookstore in London that specialized in children's literature—sometimes local shops have hidden gems. Online auctions like Sotheby's or Christie's also list signed Travers books, though they can be pricey. Don’t overlook book fairs or conventions; I met a seller at the New York Antiquarian Book Fair who had a pristine signed first edition. Condition is key, so inspect photos carefully or ask for a certificate of authenticity. Persistence pays off in this hunt!

How Many Mary Poppins Books Did P L Travers Publish?

4 answers2025-06-02 10:24:12
As someone who grew up enchanted by the whimsical world of Mary Poppins, I can confidently say that P.L. Travers published eight books in the series. The first, 'Mary Poppins,' came out in 1934, and the last, 'Mary Poppins and the House Next Door,' was published in 1988. Each book is a treasure trove of magic and life lessons, with Mary's adventures taking her and the Banks children to fantastical places like Cherry Tree Lane and the stars. Travers' writing has a timeless charm, blending British humor with profound wisdom. The sequels include 'Mary Poppins Comes Back,' 'Mary Poppins Opens the Door,' and 'Mary Poppins in the Park,' among others. The series evolved over the decades, but the core of Mary's mysterious, no-nonsense personality remained intact. For fans of classic children's literature, these books are a must-read, offering a deeper dive into Mary's world than the films ever could.

Who Published The First P L Travers Mary Poppins Novel?

4 answers2025-06-02 08:57:30
As a lifelong fan of classic children's literature, I've always been fascinated by the origins of beloved stories like 'Mary Poppins'. The first novel in the series, simply titled 'Mary Poppins', was published in 1934 by the London-based publishing house Harcourt, Brace & Company. This book introduced the world to the magical nanny who arrives with the east wind and changes the lives of the Banks family forever. P.L. Travers, the author, crafted a character so iconic that she has endured for generations, inspiring numerous adaptations, including the famous Disney film. The original publisher, Harcourt, played a crucial role in bringing this timeless story to readers, setting the stage for its global success. The novel's blend of whimsy, warmth, and subtle life lessons continues to resonate with both children and adults, making it a cornerstone of children's literature.
สำรวจและอ่านนวนิยายดีๆ ได้ฟรี
เข้าถึงนวนิยายดีๆ จำนวนมากได้ฟรีบนแอป GoodNovel ดาวน์โหลดหนังสือที่คุณชอบและอ่านได้ทุกที่ทุกเวลา
อ่านหนังสือฟรีบนแอป
สแกนรหัสเพื่ออ่านบนแอป
DMCA.com Protection Status