Okay, if you’re looking through Goodreads for people who recommend books like 'Beautiful Disaster', I dive into those threads all the time and here’s what I notice most readers point to.
A ton of fans on Goodreads who loved 'Beautiful Disaster' tend to suggest 'Thoughtless' by S.C. Stephens, 'Easy' by Tammara Webber, 'Slammed' and 'Ugly Love' by Colleen Hoover, and 'Fallen Too Far' by Abbi Glines. They usually tag them under 'new adult', 'bad boy romance', or 'angsty romance' and talk about the same pull-push chemistry, messy characters, and college/young-adult settings. You'll also see recommendations for 'Archer's Voice' by Mia Sheridan and 'Real' by Katy Evans if you like broody male leads.
What I personally do on Goodreads is follow people whose reviews match my taste—check their 'favorite' shelves, note who gives detailed spoiler-free impressions, and then follow them. Also don't miss 'Walking Disaster', which flips perspectives on the same story; it's a common rec in those comment threads and often helps decide whether you want more Travis or a different angle on the plot.