It's fascinating how these adaptations reflect different eras of comic publishing. The Innovation version came out during the early 90s boom when painted comics were a huge trend, aiming for a 'prestige' feel. The IDW/Yoe version from 2012 is part of that wave of literary adaptations meant to bring classic novels to the graphic novel audience. They serve different purposes, honestly. One is a period piece of comics history, and the other is a modern, concise introduction to the story. If you're a completionist or a fan of comic art history, both are worth tracking down. If you just want to read the story in comic form once, the newer one is perfectly serviceable and easier to obtain.