The show got the characters so profoundly wrong in places that fanfiction feels almost like a correction, a return to what the original 'Love, Simon' premise promised. In the series, Victor's relationships sometimes pivot on these manufactured crises—another love triangle, another parental disapproval scene. Writers in the fandom seem to pull those dynamics apart to find quieter, more human moments instead. They'll take a throwaway line about Victor's faith or his family's financial stress and spin an entire story around how that background noise affects his connection with Benji or Rahim, not as drama fuel but as texture.
A lot of the stronger fic I've read ignores the later-season chaos entirely, sticking closer to the first-season tone. There's a focus on the awkward, gentle building of something between Victor and Benji before all the secrets and breakups. Writers fill in the gaps the show raced past: the first real conversation after the kiss, the nervous introduction to friends, the quiet panic of realizing you're in deep. It's less about will-they-won't-they and more about how-they-do, which I find infinitely more satisfying.
Also, the way fanfiction handles side characters pairing off is fascinating. Like, fics exploring Felix and Pilar often give them more shared interiority than the show managed, building a rapport based on mutual understanding of family weirdness rather than just plot convenience. Same with Lake and Lucy—fics exploring that relationship dive into the social dynamics of their different friend groups in a way the show only gestured at. It feels like writers are using the framework of the show to tell the stories the framework itself was too busy to properly tell.